Also, thanks for reading it, it means a lot to hear such comment. I get to learn from it too :)
Indeed, there are some points in your reply which I think would fit better to a networkx vs. memgraph comparison post.
That being said, your blogpost is titled "Who ranks better?" and it is mainly about the speed of running a PageRank.
Networkx is a no frills Python package that is much easier to use and experiment on. Outperforming networkx in speed is not really a feat, however any new network package should certainly do this. And further, do this with networkx on equal footing. For instance, igraph outperforms networkX in pageRank by 20 times, and graph-tool by over 50 times (without load times)!
And I am sure memgraph can do so as well, just that this blog post doesn't seem to conclusively demonstrate that fact.
It would make little sense to me to use networkx as a tool to load data from memgraph. And to be honest, using this triple (quadruple) Python list operation and not even use the numpy-based performance that networkx does offer (little as it may be) just doesn't seem right.
I understand that memgraph has other advantages, like persistence, however in that case networkX is simply not a good comparison. If that's the focus, why not query a local Neo4j? That's gonna be a pretty speedy PageRank as well and an interesting challenge.
All in all, I am sure Memgraph performs great, and I am looking forward to other comparisons in the future!
And then you dont even use the numpy or scipy implementation of networkx. If inmemory, benchmark networkx by loading a sp matrix and use the numpy pagerank and only time that?
Like, it’s not as if anyone uses networkx for performance, so dunking on it for that is probably not as good of a marketing post as it seems.
But then also check your implementation bc this surely is the slowest way to use networkx and then having only five times speed up seems little. Doesn’t igraph or julia beat properly implemented networkx by much more?
Look, if it weren’t an advertisement I would not say anything, but it seems you compare your new performance car with the networkx family van, which is also maybe filled with concrete.