And even this punts on perceptive utility, the kind that Nozick warns us about[1]: it's entirely possible that Johnny in Country X gets more utility out of $100 in charitable giving than 50 others in Country Y. But this seems like a really bad logical consequence, the kind that the Internet Rationalist EA community uses to justify spending money on AGI research instead of donating to AMF.
Overall, it's much easier to live in a world where we can determine that some set of charities are worth giving to, and not try too hard to order between them.
Do you think that some charities are more effective than other ones?
Do you think we should try to measure that to determine which ones are more effective?
Most charitable donations are net good. Sure there exist a small subset of charities that aren't probably doing harm but that's the exception.
Would you argue that charitable giving is neutral or bad?
But I suppose I would say it's neutral; it could be good or bad depending on various characteristics of the charity itself.
But do you at least agree the government does less good with 20 cents than a givewell charity like the AMF does with a dollar?
It's certainly the scale of impact difference between some of the charities:
Charities can be useless or actively harmful: https://www.givewell.org/international/technical/criteria/im...
vs.
$4500/life saved: https://www.givewell.org/our-giving-funds#Top_Charities_Fund
They also say why it's that high: https://www.givewell.org/impact-estimates
Another example I've heard is hospitals asking people to stop skydiving to raise money for them, as the mean cost of medial care the average skydiver needs due to skydiving injuries exceeds the average money raised by skydiving.
AMF and other top givewell charities seem far more focused on the good they can do than more classic charities like WWF or Plan Parenthood.