Cash that’s been paid out from a bankrupt company can be clawed back by the bankrupty trustee. Usually this only applies to payments made shortly before the company goes under though.
Quite true. And I've not followed the details about SBF's schemes...but it sounds like he's different from Madoff in three important respects, all of which seem likely to make claw-backs less viable:
- Diverting funds to cover trading losses at an allied & now-bankrupt firm. If Madoff had (say) directly lost $1B by buying some stock which then fell in value, would there have been any possible claw-back on that $1B? I'd bet "no".
- Lots of funds were "laundered" through various sorts of crypto transactions. Anything "crypto" is probably a far greasier pig, to try to wrestle the real money back.
- Layers of corporate structure, HQ'ed in an offshore tax haven. IANAL, and certainly not a lawyer qualified in tax haven corporate securities law, but this sounds more like a gold mine for the lawyers than good news for the victims.
Vs. the vague and amorphous "money", which so easily flows from being bits in a computer here, to marks on a sheet of paper there, to bits in some other computer... The emotions of the neutral human observer don't stick to it nearly so tightly. And a huge number of politicians, business exec's, lawyers, and other "friends" of white collar crime are naturally quite resistant to the "you should give it back" notions of the little people...