News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by palata on Sunday November 20, 2022 @07:58PM (#33687400)
Not sure I get your point. Say you use IRCCloud on your phone, you don't need anything else, do you?
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by Filligree on Sunday November 20, 2022 @09:32PM (#33687990)
IRCCloud regularly gets stuck, has to be manually reset, doesn’t cope well with network changes and seems to have database overloads once per day.

I use it, but discord’s mobile client is a far better experience.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by palata on Monday November 21, 2022 @05:57PM (#33699358)
But this is not fundamentally a limitation of the IRC protocol, is it?
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by Filligree on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @10:01AM (#33706520)
It’s got nothing to do with the IRC protocol. The mobile application is effectively a remote for a client running in their datacenter.

I’m just pointing out that… well, discord has advantages other than the protocol.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by lmm on Sunday November 20, 2022 @10:00PM (#33688184)
IRCCloud is fine, but it's more expensive than Discord, the UX is not quite as nice for reasons inherent to the IRC model, and it's not really more open in any substantive sense (my phone will be running the proprietary IRCCloud application that speaks a proprietary IRCCloud protocol). So why would one bother?
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by palata on Monday November 21, 2022 @05:55PM (#33699324)
> and it's not really more open in any substantive sense [...]. So why would one bother?

Not for you, because you want to use a turnkey solution, and you don't want to pay for it (instead relying on whatever model they have where you are the product, I guess?). But if you use IRC to talk to me, I can run my own bouncer for free, and I can run the client I want. I can even write my bouncer and my client, and still talk to you.

That's infinitely more open than Discord. It's just that you don't care about others.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by lmm on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @01:24AM (#33702690)
> Not for you, because you want to use a turnkey solution, and you don't want to pay for it (instead relying on whatever model they have where you are the product, I guess?). But if you use IRC to talk to me, I can run my own bouncer for free, and I can run the client I want. I can even write my bouncer and my client, and still talk to you.

> That's infinitely more open than Discord. It's just that you don't care about others.

I care a bit about whether you can run your bouncer. But I also care about whether non-technical people can talk to me without an unreasonable level of effort. Expecting everyone else to pay extra for a worse experience so that you can use it the way you want seems pretty entitled.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by palata on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @11:45AM (#33707749)
> Expecting everyone else to pay extra for a worse experience so that you can use it the way you want seems pretty entitled.

Yeah, the price is an issue indeed. I guess that's why we keep having monopolies: it's easier to get VC money if you can ensure user lock-in, and it's easier to make a nice UX if you have VC money.

Now, don't think you don't pay those proprietary messengers. You just pay differently.