My gameplay involves 32 human players playing against each other in football for a title that only one can win. Each season takes a month.
That's 32 shades of grey, with 31 of those shades being losses.
How do you rubber band that? I'm about to build a facebook app for our game, and I'm trying to brain storm solutions to this problem.
The only answer I have so far is make 32 team leagues, with 16 fairly inept CPU players. But not indicate they are CPUs, so that humans believe they are beating 31 other humans, even though the reality is they are beating 15.
This cuts my problem by a lot, but adds overhead, and removes a lot of the challenge.
I would suggest banding things so 20 teams compete for a spot in the playoffs which consists of 16 teams. (aka 16 people get a win at the cost of 4.) And in the actual playoffs you only lose one game, so rank people based on what round they get to. Something like winner!, (A++) lost final game, (A+) final 4, (A) final 8, (B) got into playoffs, (Try again)did not get into playoffs.
The secret is letting people move on as soon as they can't win any more while making them feel like getting as far as they did is still worth something. Lost the first 6 games? Hey start over it's ok, I hope you learned how the game worked etc.
A football like game. There's nothing wrong with a football like game, but we're a simulation.
Would sort of defeat the purpose. The way to do it in our case probably involves outside "goals" like...
"Obtain a Quarterback over 90 overall."
Or something similar.... Things you can accomplish, outside of the normal system.
Speed up gameplay with UI improvements, etc, so that players can compete in more simultaneous (staggered) competitions, increasing their chance of a good score.
Do you have a tunable AI to test players against, for making sure they get into the right skill-group? If people are in a good group they'll enjoy a loss more than if they're totally outmatched but somehow forced to play it out. The game takes so long it'd be discouraging to try to learn it while losing badly. Maybe let people drop out at any point (to join a game starting today), and be replaced by a bot of their skill? This could also handle no-shows.
How is the game played? Is it like fantasy football? It there a screenshot of what the game looks like? Are real teams and players in the game? You should consider answering these questions on the home page.
I am really quite poor at the design, and work flow. I mostly spend my time trying to make the most accurate game play as possible.
So I am usually doing statistical analysis on how much yac is the average gained for throws behind the back field, and things like that. Focusing so much on the details, I lose sight of a lot of the core things a website like this needs.
To answer your questions
"How is the game played?"
You choose a league, and then a team. From there, you are playing in a football league with 31 other people. The football year goes, Free Agency, Draft, Preseason, Regular Season, Playoffs, Repeat.
Different leagues have different rates of play, but I always play 1 spin a day. That's most popular. So every day 1 spin occurs. Most of the time, that is one game day. So every day, a new game is played. You check out the results, make adjustments. Do it all over again. Make some trades, remove guys because of injury. Sign replacements.
"Is it like fantasy football?"
No. It is more about the football management side of a real pro football team.
"Is there a screenshot of what the game looks like"?"
The game is the website. I think the most valuable thing here would probably be a link to what a boxscore looks like. What a gamelog looks like. Pieces of the game like that.
I have made some recorded sessions that I put on youtube, but it's sort of me talking over me playing.
"Are real teams and players in the game?"
This is coming with the start of me working on a facebook version.
How this works I am still working out. At the moment, it would be just allowing you to practice your team against real teams. Perhaps there's a ladder outside of normal gameplay to beat all the real teams.
Not sure. Lots of ideas. I could even run reality back from.. I don't know.. 1994.. and you could reexperience the drafts that occurred.
I really should answer them on the home page.. Not sure how they should look.
Again.. I'm not good at design, so I tend to focus on what I am good at, and the other stuff doesn't get done :)
Have you ever read "The Smart Money"? It's about some hacker gamblers who built a simulator and placed their bets according to its results. Ever since I read it I have wanted my own simulator to play around with. I'm not a gambler, but I thought it would be neat to make a game out of it. I don't have a background in statistics and realized very quickly that I would be in over my head trying to make one myself. I'm glad you did the work and I can just play!
A very weak player will likely lose the first two or three matches in a row, but then have a real chance against some other weak player.
So far the biggest mistake I believe I've made is not cheating to help players win. I made a brutally difficult simulation game.
We have tons of players quit simply because the game is too hard. Because you are 1 person versus 31 other people, there is only 1 winner, and 31 losers.
People don't like this.
Compare this to our competitors, and they make losses not exist, and otherwise "cheat" the experience so everyone is above average.
The worst player in the games, looks like he is the best.
There has to be a happy medium somewhere, and I am the ruthless simulation side of it for now. (Trying to figure out how to change...)