News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by tsimionescu on Saturday November 19, 2022 @12:23PM (#33672229)
> So is what you're saying is your concept of freedom of speech is the correct version? You've also not backed up anything as to support your "much more likely" claim.

First of all, Elon has always said that he intends to practice "freedom of speech, but not freedom of reach" - which he explains to mean "we won't ban your account, we will just stop showing your tweets to everyone if it's not the right kind of speech". So already this idea that he believes in absolute freedom of speech is obviously wrong.

Secondly, he has a long history of seeking to silence his critics. Firing employees that publicly contradict him is mostly understandable; but accusing the rescue diver that said his ideas were stupid of pedophilia, and hiring PIs to try to "prove" it, is certainly not.

Thirdly, freedom of speech is a relatively simple idea - it means that you believe people should be free to make their opinions known without being silenced or unduly punished for opinions. There are various complex issues related to the details of what it means to silence or unduly punish, and to cases where the freedom of speech of two individuals can come in conflict. But it is very clear that someone who supports freedom to express certain legal opinions and NOT other legal opinions is not in fact advocating for freedom of speech.

> Are people not allowed to be upset if a brand starts introducing content they don't want their children to be exposed to, whether you agree with that or not?

They are allowed, but they are not allowed to then also claim that they are pro free speech.

> Do you support influencing, manipulation, of children and young teenagers towards permanently physically altering their body - like cutting off their breasts?

No, and neither does anyone else beyond some demented extremists. I do support children and teenagers getting access to medicine that allows them to live the best life they can, and if their doctor and parents agree that involves puberty blockers, I support them having access to that.

Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by loceng on Saturday November 19, 2022 @12:29PM (#33672302)
'First of all, Elon has always said that he intends to practice "freedom of speech, but not freedom of reach"'

First sentence and you already moved goalpost.

Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by tsimionescu on Saturday November 19, 2022 @12:55PM (#33672656)
My point was that Elon's notion of separating "freedom of speech" from "freedom of reach" is already counter to the basic ideal of freedom of speech. By this same standard, the US government could claim that a law preventing sales of a particular book would not put them in breach of the 1st amendment, as they are still allowing the book to exist.
Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by loceng on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:24PM (#33673662)
You're conflating the government with a private citizen's private enterprise. The U.S. government can't block the sale of a book AFAIK - unless perhaps it's things like "how to build a nuclear bomb."

Elon's Twitter is his house - his house, his rules. If someone's going to be racist in his house and he doesn't want racist/immature narratives being propagated - then he has the power to limit that; we don't know what limiting the reach means either, perhaps depending on the severity it means that only your specific followers see it - and that it isn't shown to random people.

Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by tsimionescu on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:14PM (#33674153)
Freedom of speech is freedom of speech. If you think that the US government isn't legally allowed to limit speech in a certain way because of the 1st amendment, than any private entity who is limitting speech in that way can't claim they support free speech.

Of course, private entities, unlike the government, have every right to limit freedom of speech on their own property. But they can't then claim they are supporters of freedom of speech on their platform.