News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by ericd on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:26AM (#33670960)
I don’t think the parent’s tone was good for discussion, but HN is literally all links off to other sites with some meta-discussion, it’s not “centralized”.
Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by yunwal on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:34AM (#33671033)
Could almost say the same thing about twitter. It’s mostly short quips and links to longer-form content.
Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by robobro on Saturday November 19, 2022 @11:00AM (#33671300)
If someone tries to argue that Twitter isn't centralized, I don't think they really understand what centralization means.
Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by TobyTheDog123 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:43AM (#33671134)
Twitter links out to content all the time - is that decentralized? Where's the line?

- It's hosted on servers presumably operated by a centralized entity (YCombinator/AWS/etc)

- It has moderation centralized to a specific set of people (which is weird sentence construction but I had to fit centralized in there for the point)

- Post content (even links), comments, accounts, etc, are stored in a centralized database (might be sharded or whatever, but you get the point, the control is centralized)

- It has a domain name and DNS records that are centralized to ICANN/whoever-hosts-the-dns

Centralization, to me at least, is about how content is delivered, not about how likely the product is to bounce you to an external source.

Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by robobro on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:59AM (#33671297)
HN isn't just links. It's also discussion threads. It is centralized in that these links and discussions don't happen in some abstract cloud that's not strictly limited to this instance managed by our BDFL
Re:Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social by ericd on Saturday November 19, 2022 @05:49PM (#33675717)
Right, I mean more that it’s not actively trying to keep people on-site by eg hosting the content, it’s a jumping off point to the rest of the decentralized internet. But it’s not a federated service, its hosting is centralized. Two different aspects of centralization.