It was true twenty years ago too, the only difference I can see between then and now is that you can outsource that task for a (relatively) small amount of money if you want to.
Then again, the last time I dealt with a site under DDoS, something in their stack was leaking the underlying IP (never did figure out what) but it turned out that "finding a provider who'd sell them a decent sized server and charge them for the bandwidth" was perfectly economical for their use case because their haters' firepower was insufficient compared to their revenue.
(I'd love to be less vague here but I'm sure readers can see the obvious professional ethics issues with doing so)
And if you run that in a cloud, the NAT isn't your problem -> your attacker will have to DoS that cloud as a whole.
Part of the art of consultancy is, sometimes to my great annoyance, optimising for "within the customer's budget" and "within the customer's capacity to maintain it after I'm no longer involved" over "best possible solution."
Plus in this particular case I was working pro bono because (a) I quite liked the site in question continuing to exist (b) a Shadowcat alumnus asked me nicely (c) I take great pleasure in ruining a griefer's entire week. So lightest possible touch was strongly indicated.
The end result was not remotely clever, but it's been in production for a while now and has not to my knowledge caused financial or uptime issues, so I'm going to call it a win even if the inelegance of -how- I won continues to irritate me ;)
Fortunately, while said quantity was indeed aggravating, it was low enough that the cost was financially and logistically less than trying to do something more elegant.
Sometimes brute force and ignorance is, in fact, the right answer, and I don't have to -like- that being true for it to be true.
Why do you think they're still "good"? CloudFlare has chosen to abandon sites that held free speech (abhorrent speech, but still free speech) while still protecting forums upon which credit cards and methamphetamine were listed for sale on the front page.
To me, that's not a sign of a "good" actor.
So many people find them abhorrent because they represent different values.
Legally no one has any obligations here.
RE bots: TikTok has incredible bot protection that comes from engineering (webmssdk) instead of network-based filtering. I'm not even sure if they use Cloudflare.
We take every reported false negative as an opportunity to improve our DDoS mitigations, and these reports are very helpful.
As of a few weeks ago, you can now report FNs/FPs for Bot Mitigation directly in the dashboard, and we'll be expanding this pattern for use with DDoS Mitigation as well.
However, being on both sides of this, both operating a bot for my search engine, and operating a web service that is aggressively targeted by bots. They're not actually bad to deal with.
The big unanswered question is how they'll manage to stay good given the obvious incentive of abusing this setup. Maybe this CEO has a moral backbone, but will the next, and when they're acquired by the Meta-Amazon-Alphabet group in 15 years, will they still stick to these principles?