News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by flanked-evergl on Saturday November 19, 2022 @04:45AM (#33668649)
> and that nothing was true until a social consensus had been reached between mathematicians.

So how do calculators and computers work then?

Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by yazaddaruvala on Saturday November 19, 2022 @04:48AM (#33668671)
1+1=2 is a social construct.

It’s simple, repeatable and therefore programable - but still a social construct.

Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by jojobas on Saturday November 19, 2022 @05:02AM (#33668762)
Well if "1+1=2" is a social construct then "there are planets, stars, and, in general, objects" is also a social construct. No kind of society can make 1+1=3, and also there is mathematical proof that 1+1=2 (built of course on some sort of axioms that somebody might also consider social constructs).
Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by prmph on Saturday November 19, 2022 @06:28AM (#33669211)
Imagine a universe, where, when you combine two apples (or really anything), you always, through some weird physical process, end up with three items.

Would that invalidate (or not), the statement that 1 + 1 = 2?

Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by eesmith on Saturday November 19, 2022 @06:52AM (#33669330)
1 cloud combined with 1 cloud gives 1 cloud.
Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by feanaro on Saturday November 19, 2022 @07:22AM (#33669490)
That's just some additional structure pertaining to, specifically, clouds. One cloud standing close to another cloud still equals two clouds, which is what 1 + 1 = 2 is really encoding.
Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by eesmith on Saturday November 19, 2022 @07:01AM (#33669375)
We know "planet" is a social construct because the astronomers decided, some years back, that Pluto wasn't a planet.

And the rules they created to make that definition only apply in the Solar System, not to exoplanets around other stars nor to rogue/free-floating planets.

And Ceres, Pallas, Juno, and Vesta were considered planets for over half a century.

Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by jojobas on Saturday November 19, 2022 @06:56PM (#33676382)
In order to decide whether Pluto is a planet, one has to assume that there are, in fact, planets. This assumption is not social in nature, it's language describing natural, inarguable phenomena.
Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by eesmith on Sunday November 20, 2022 @01:48AM (#33678907)
Does "marriage" exist, as a "natural, inarguable phenomena" independent of its social construct?

What about "US citizen"?

I don't think so.

Which means we can't say the existence of a word means its the result of a physical assumption.

When you wrote "planets, stars", did you not assume those two are different? But originally, "planet" meant "wandering star" - a planet was assumed to be a type of star.

Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by mik1998 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @07:28AM (#33669523)
It's not. It's a fact derived a priori from the definition of addition and the axioms of the field of real numbers. There's nothing special about the claim that 1 + 1 = 2. You can also define addition such that 1 + 1 = 0 or anything else.
Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by yazaddaruvala on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:11AM (#33670193)
“a priori from the definition of addition” is effectively saying “a social construct”

And I hate to break it to you but all “axioms” are social constructs that we use to create hopefully useful models.

Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by mik1998 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @09:59AM (#33670667)
No, this is not true at all. It is a certain _mathematical_ construction. It has nothing to do with society. Given the specific definition of addition in the field of real numbers, the statement 1 + 1 = 2 is true in any society.

> but all “axioms” are social constructs

Again, they are mathematical constructs. Axioms don't have anything to do with society. I can construct any axiom I want, and derive true statements from it. Perhaps the only "social" thing here is what axioms we generally deem interesting enough to investigate - this does not change the facts derived from them.

> that we use to create hopefully useful models.

I think you underestimate pure mathematics :)

Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by yazaddaruvala on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:00PM (#33674010)
I’ll try one last time:

> definition of addition

What do you think any definition is other than the creation of a socially shared construct?

> I can construct any axiom I want, and derive true statements from it.

Let’s test this. Axiomatically I am always right! As such, I derive that it is illogical, dare I say irrational, of you to disagree with me. A truer statement has never even been written! Facts!

Hmm… turns out you disagree that it’s a true statement. Why? I had an axiom! You don’t agree with my axiom? If that’s allowed, I guess I’ll have to convince you (and society) of my axiom!

Re:Computer Proof ‘Blows Up’ Centuries-Old Fluid Equations by mik1998 on Sunday November 20, 2022 @05:13AM (#33679779)
> What do you think any definition is other than the creation of a socially shared construct?

A definition is simply a definition. It doesn't have to be social or shared. I can define addition in any manner, and in fact there are many other definitions of addition.

> Let’s test this. Axiomatically I am always right! As such, I derive that it is illogical, dare I say irrational, of you to disagree with me. A truer statement has never even been written! Facts!

You have a very interesting misunderstanding here. A fact is true only relative to an axiom. So yes, relative to such an axiom you are right, similarly how relative to the axioms of the field of real numbers the statement 1 + 1 = 2 is true.

You can construct any axiom and derive facts from it. I can construct axioms such that 1 + 1 = 0. That doesn't make the statement 1 + 1 = 2 in the real numbers any less false!