News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad? by edanm on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @08:37AM (#33622665)
> This is the part of EA that triggers a lot of red flags for me. Making money, or rather making significant money, necessitates participation in a system of exploitation that is largely responsible for the ills the charitable donations are meant to alleviate in the first place.

I mean, given that you think that I understand where you're coming from. But just note that many, many people would highly disagree with that characterization.

I don't think our "system", whatever that means, is evil. I think it's pretty good, definitely better than other things people have come up with. And I don't think you need to give to charity to morality-wash greed. I think it's just the right thing to do.

Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad? by skinnymuch on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @08:54AM (#33622888)
You missed the major point of being the exact capitalists that are the reason for charity to be so necessary. That’s white washing greed and self interest. Get to have a better life selfishly then donate the money to be morally better.
Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad? by edanm on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @09:02AM (#33623027)
No I didn't miss the point. I disagree with it.

Looking at other countries that don't have capitalism, everyone is worse off. I don't think capitalism is the reason charity is necessary. I think the world starts default-bad for humans, by default we don't have anywhere close to the living we want, and over the years, many technological advanacements, including capitalism, have slowly made most humans far better off.

This is fairly clear in the historical record or in comparing different countries.

(At least to me. Most people seem to disagree with this, but I honestly think they're wrong.)

Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @09:05AM (#33623086)
> Looking at other countries that don't have capitalism, everyone is worse off.

Interesting that all I talked about was a system of exploitation and your mind immediately filled in 'capitalism'.

I think there are many countries that temper capitalism with socialist ideals and people are not worse off than the more unfettered variety practiced in the US.

Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad? by edanm on Thursday November 17, 2022 @04:12AM (#33636578)
> Interesting that all I talked about was a system of exploitation and your mind immediately filled in 'capitalism'.

That's not what happened. When I answered you I wrote "the system". I answered skinnymuch's post about capitalism, because they themselves talked about capitalism.

But out of curiosity - what "system" exactly did you have in mind?

> I think there are many countries that temper capitalism with socialist ideals and people are not worse off than the more unfettered variety practiced in the US.

Who said anything about the US?

Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad? by skinnymuch on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:02PM (#33628637)
The point as the OP is saying as well is that people are being unfairly exploited in capitalism. You went along with agreeing with me by arguing about capitalism which is what I called the system of exploitation as said by the OP.
Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad? by zajio1am on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @01:29PM (#33628059)
Well, without capitalism everyone would live in subsistence-level poverty, but it would be a social norm, so no charity would be necessary.