As to "the rest of the civilized world", as pointed out several times now, very little of the "civilized" world has strong speech protections. Germany? Laws against Holocaust denial and defamatory fake news[1], which sounds Orwellian. France isn't pro-free speech either[2]. The UK has the backwards Communication Act and libel laws that are criticised the world over[3], leading to hundreds of convictions a year[4], including for posting your favourite rap lyrics[5]. Canada's free speech protections are anything but[6]. Australia has "less protection of free speech than most Western countries" according to a former High Court judge and there are raids on journalists[7], which we know happens in the US all too regularly[8] as well despite its much lauded first amendment. Italy charges writers for expressing opinions[9]. Perhaps I could complete the G8 with the state of free speech in Russia? Or you'd like to move on to places like Norway that only managed to get rid of its lese majeste laws in 2015? Or Thailand that still has them. Germany only got rid of its lese majeste laws in 2018 after a dictator tried to use them against a satririst, which brings us full circle and we haven't even touched the worst parts of the world.
[1] https://apnews.com/article/europe-germany-business-3d266e6de...
[2] https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/press-release/2020/11/fran...
[3] https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2015/03/21/394273902/...
[4] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/arrests-for-offensive-...
[5] https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-merseyside-43816921#main...
[6] https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/despite-what-you-may-th...
[7] https://theconversation.com/australia-doesnt-protect-free-sp...
[8] https://freedom.press/news/2020-report-journalists-arrested-...
I'll gladly accept that my definition of free speech differs from the "civilized world" that has no clue what free speech is and has basically no interest in protecting it.
Nobody supports unlimited free speech. Everyone accepts there needs to be certain limits. Suppose there is a billionaire with a very dark personality, and you are a low-paid waiter in a restaurant. He's unhappy with the service you provided, and is in a particularly angry mood today, so he instructs his minions to falsely label you as a child molester, and spends millions spreading that false accusation across the globe, simply as a way of hurting you–does any one really think "free speech" should include the right to that kind of speech? But if you don't, you support defamation laws as a limit on free speech at least in some extreme cases, even if you think many of those laws (as they currently exist) go way too far.
So, if we accept free speech has to be subject to some limits – the question is, where to draw those limits? How to balance freedom of speech with other freedoms (such as freedom from defamation, freedom from fraud, freedom from privacy invasion, freedom from perjury, etc)? Is there some objective answer to where those limits ought to be drawn? You seem to think that the US does a better job of drawing those limits than most other countries (or maybe even every other country)–maybe you are right, but surely that's an argument that needs to be made, rather than simply something which is self-evident (as you seem to think it is).
Some do propose this, most don't.
> the question is, where to draw those limits? How to balance freedom of speech with other freedoms (such as freedom from defamation, freedom from fraud, freedom from privacy invasion, freedom from perjury, etc)?
- freedom from defamation, provide a justice system where truth is the ultimate defence (as common law states have - it could be improved though)
- freedom from fraud, already covered by contract law and caveat emptor
- freedom from privacy invasion, that is part of free speech (you choose who you share information with, hence, privacy is implied and necessary)
- freedom from perjury, there are laws against perjury in common law
I'm sure there are other countries that actually take the notion of free speech seriously but I'm too ignorant about the laws of every country to know that. Most countries I can think of have glaring issues with protecting people's right to free speech.