Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad?
by davidgay on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @01:19AM
(#33619559)
> > Firstly, you can't predict the future so really you're working off your biases.
> Um, are you saying that this implies that people should just throw up their hands and donate to whatever causes since who knows?
No, it implies that you shouldn't lecture others that you have the one true answer as to the best path forwards. You are free to (and in fact should) use your best judgment in your own personal choices, just don't confuse that with absolute truth.
Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad?
by yanderekko on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @01:31AM
(#33619638)
I don't think EA institutions argue that they have the One True Answer. They just often give recommendations - "eg. if you care about maximizing QALY overall, we recommend charities X, Y, and Z." If I don't care about QALY maximization, fine. But if I do, why would I not listen to the recommendations?
Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad?
by TedDoesntTalk on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:40AM
(#33620475)
Longtermism and QALY do not seem compatible.
Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad?
by xorfish on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @08:39AM
(#33622683)
EA and Longtermism are not the same thing.
Um, are you saying that this implies that people should just throw up their hands and donate to whatever causes since who knows? Surely not. Once we acknowledge that these questions can be tackled empirically, that's what EA tries to do. Is there room for bias in this process? Absolutely. Does that justify embracing some sort of epistemic nihilism? Absolutely not.