News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by brigandish on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:02PM (#33617046)
If I ask you something nicely and you come back with "Stop bothering me about it", how do you think that would come off?
Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by test098 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:34PM (#33617303)
Like someone exercising free speech?
Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by brigandish on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:32PM (#33617717)
Whether someone is exercising their free speech is not relevant to the perception of hostility in a comment, or similar kind of assessment, unless it involves a (at least perceived) threat of imminent danger. That's clearly not the case here so I'm afraid I can't help answer your question, rhetorical or not, as it's missed the point somewhat.
Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by test098 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:19PM (#33618392)
That was a reference to your line, "It seems that not only has 'community of leftist[s]' given up on free speech (as is the vogue)..."

You seem to place quite a bit of value in free speech, yet are bothered when the creators of this project use theirs to set boundaries, going so far as to call it "hostile." It's unfortunate that you find it hostile - I consider the hateful conduct that they're banning much more hostile and support their methods of collaboration to that end.

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by brigandish on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @12:04AM (#33619124)
I called their responses in the issue thread hostile, which they were. As to the limits of free speech, they're not just limiting what they hear/see, they're deciding to do that for others too. That seems to go against the ideas of free speech and of federation, especially in the open source space.

> It's unfortunate that you find it hostile - I consider the hateful conduct that they're banning much more hostile and support their methods of collaboration to that end.

It is hostile, but how is their hostility in that case justified by their stance against certain forms of prejudice? I don't see the justification. Moreover, the list of prejudices (if they are, they're just vague assertions at this point) they gave is not necessarily hostile. For example, a racist might publish a paper saying that the IQ of one race is less than another's. That is racist but not hostile. If they were to write "thus we should eliminate them" or "I hate them because of this" or, to a member of that race were to show any sort of aggression for simply being of that race, that would be hostile. It is eminently possible (and I'd say, easy) to be against hostility of any sort discussed here, and against racism while also noting that they're not synonyms and that they don't always overlap.

Nuance exists, even when discussing prejudice.

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by test098 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:35PM (#33629244)
> As to the limits of free speech, they're not just limiting what they hear/see, they're deciding to do that for others too

It's their project, they can do what they please with it. This is the premise of FOSS, which makes no claims as to how maintainers must communicate with collaborators or how projects must be maintained.

> go against the ideas of free speech and of federation, especially in the open source space

Those are your values, not the values of the maintainers. Maybe their relationship to open source is different than yours. Maybe their idea of free speech is different than yours. This is no more than you forcing your values on them.

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by brigandish on Thursday November 17, 2022 @12:22AM (#33635297)
> It's their project, they can do what they please with it.

Who was questioning that? No one, thanks for noticing.

> This is the premise of FOSS, which makes no claims as to how maintainers must communicate with collaborators or how projects must be maintained.

It is not, however, any protection against criticism about what they choose to do with that project. If you open source a program that actively harms any or all of the groups the Lemmy project is (ostensibly) trying to protect in its claim, would that protect you from criticism? Not in the slightest.

> > go against the ideas of free speech and of federation, especially in the open source space

> Those are your values, not the values of the maintainers.

Again, thanks for noticing.

> Maybe their relationship to open source is different than yours.

And?

> Maybe their idea of free speech is different than yours.

Clearly, it's why I'm criticising them.

> This is no more than you forcing your values on them.

Pray tell how I have applied force?

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by test098 on Friday November 18, 2022 @05:41PM (#33663632)
> Who was questioning that? No one, thanks for noticing.

You're welcome! I'm pointing that out because apparently you haven't noticed that, hence your criticism.

> It is not, however, any protection against criticism about what they choose to do with that project. If you open source a program that actively harms any or all of the groups the Lemmy project is (ostensibly) trying to protect in its claim, would that protect you from criticism? Not in the slightest.

Yeah, I'm not debating that.

> Again, thanks for noticing.

Again, you're welcome!

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by brigandish on Friday November 18, 2022 @08:07PM (#33665479)
> apparently you haven't noticed that, hence your criticism.

If you conflate criticism with being against freedom then I can see why you'd come to this erroneous conclusion, and many of the others you've made.

> Yeah, I'm not debating that.

It's not protection against criticism but to criticise is against the freedom of the project. Right.

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by Quarrelsome on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:48PM (#33617409)
> If I ask you something nicely

Asking nicely is when you submit a PR as well IMHO.

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by brigandish on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:33PM (#33617728)
As we're discussing a Reddit alternative it seems apt to use the phrase "username checks out".

No, asking nicely is not limited to issues that come with a PR.

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by Quarrelsome on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:40AM (#33621134)
I just think if devs are working on smth for free and I want them to add a feature and they tell me they don't want to then complaining about their attitude is a waste of time as well as rather unbecoming.

> As we're discussing a Reddit alternative it seems apt to use the phrase "username checks out".

Really?

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by brigandish on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @09:04AM (#33623054)
Publishing work open source is not magical protection from criticism, nor from requests, especially when using software with an issue tracker that you leave open to anyone. Whether they receive money for it or not is also irrelevant - would their reaction or their decision be better if they earnt a million quid per issue? No, so let's not bother with such facile excuses.

Furthermore, I haven't added anything to the project's issue tracker, and I didn't criticise them for turning down a request but the way they reacted to a request. Please try not to create straw man arguments because they're more convenient to rebut than what has actually been written, that's unbecoming.

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by Quarrelsome on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @10:07AM (#33624272)
> would their reaction or their decision be better if they earnt a million quid per issue? No, so let's not bother with such facile excuses.

It would be super relevant if they got paid a million per issue by the community because then there would be an expectation of receiving something in exchange. Project maintainers don't owe you anything, the whole point of FOSS is that this doesn't matter because you can just fork it and make your own opinionated changes to circumvent differences of opinion instead of achieving nothing but negativity by hand-wringing over tone.

> and I didn't criticise them for turning down a request but the way they reacted to a request.

We can tone police the OP of that thread as well if you like. The way the OP effectively says:

> this [what currently happens] is just bad

> this [what I want] is much more sensible

has the same capacity to appear aggressive in nature.

Re:Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative by brigandish on Thursday November 17, 2022 @12:27AM (#33635327)
> there would be an expectation of receiving something in exchange

What's the issue tracker for and why is open beyond the core team?

> We can tone police the OP of that thread as well if you like. The way the OP effectively says:

> > this [what currently happens] is just bad

> > this [what I want] is much more sensible

> has the same capacity to appear aggressive in nature.

I don't see the aggression. If you ask me for something and I respond with:

- no, fuck off

- I'm sorry but I don't think that meets the current aims of this project so we won't be doing it

They're equally aggressive? Maybe you could give a better example because what I have right now is too absurd.