Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d...
by WettowelReactor on Friday December 16, 2011 @08:57AM
(#3360681)
And what if I am a paying Google Apps Customer. Video through youtube is included in what I pay for. Should UMG have the right to control that as well?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d...
by alex_c on Friday December 16, 2011 @09:35AM
(#3360793)
That seems to be between you and Google. If paying for Google Apps doesn't result in having reliable video hosting, then Google's service may not be worth it. UMG's "rights" don't really come into it if this is a voluntary agreement between Google and UMG.
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d...
by Silhouette on Friday December 16, 2011 @10:22AM
(#3360925)
Interesting. Do you get something contractually guaranteed as a Googe Apps customer that is different to Joe Public uploading a video to YouTube? If so, are you able to link to exactly what your agreement says?
I think it would change the situation significantly if the organisation whose video was pulled in this case had actually been paying Google to host it for them on some sort of contractual basis, and the reason for Google's removal of the content was not a legal obligation but another private commercial deal.
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d...
by WettowelReactor on Friday December 16, 2011 @02:52PM
(#3362024)
This is what I was going for. Everyone claims you get what you pay for but it is important to remember that some users do pay for Google services. What is worrisome is how Goggles actions in this case would apply to those users.
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d...
by FireBeyond on Friday December 16, 2011 @11:44AM
(#3361163)
Video -hosting- (and ancillary features) is included in what you pay for.
Access to other parties videos? Is not.
And the party you contracted with (Google) has contracts with other entities. Has nothing to do with "rights". If you have a problem with the contracts entered into, then act accordingly.
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d...
by WettowelReactor on Friday December 16, 2011 @02:50PM
(#3362018)
I don't mean that I should have a right to other users videos what I mean is what if I upload a video to my "paid" account that UMG takes offense too.