News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by eof on Friday December 16, 2011 @03:18AM (#3359968)
Well; I guess if they have a contract with YouTube that allows them to take down videos directly then technically they are in the (legal) right.

I assume youtube TOS allows them to pull down your video for 'any reason'; otherwise there might be some liability on youtube's end.

I did not expect this turn of events; and I wonder why youtube would sign an agreement like that at all..

Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by danmaz74 on Friday December 16, 2011 @03:41AM (#3360032)
I wonder why youtube would sign an agreement like that at all

Most likely, this could be a settlement that gives UMG and the likes a great latitude at taking down videos, and Youtube a guarantee not to get sued or some other rights.

On the other hand, if this kind of practice (let me stop whatever content I want or I'll sue you on unrelated matters) became widespread, this could have a really nasty effect on free speech rights.

Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by regularfry on Friday December 16, 2011 @03:46AM (#3360043)
They won't get sued by UMG. They could in theory be sued by uploaders.
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by officemonkey on Friday December 16, 2011 @05:38AM (#3360286)
Or worse yet, abandoned by their users.
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by FireBeyond on Friday December 16, 2011 @11:46AM (#3361168)
For what? Being denied their natural right to have content hosted by Google at no charge?

Wait, hang on...

Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by regularfry on Saturday December 17, 2011 @04:39AM (#3363905)
That's why I said "in theory". If there is an argument that YouTube would be liable for damages, following the rules of the DMCA would have given them immunity. By not following those rules, they lose that immunity.
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by ersmi on Friday December 16, 2011 @04:19AM (#3360111)
I would guess that the additional take down rights were in exchange for VEVO posting the official music videos on Youtube. The videos would increase traffic to Youtube, but the company would obviously want significant benefits for posting their protected content in a public area.
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by brudgers on Friday December 16, 2011 @09:55AM (#3360838)
>"this could have a really nasty effect on free speech rights."

Youtube is a business unit of a publicly traded company.

It has users, not citizens.

Free speech rights are irrelevant to the way in which it establishes policies.

Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by CWuestefeld on Friday December 16, 2011 @12:03PM (#3361239)
This is generally true, but not always.

- - - Quote [1]

Shopping malls are an exception to the rule. In California, the courts recognize big malls as the modern-day "functional equivalent" of a traditional public gathering place, because they have "common areas that would invite the public to meet, congregate, or engage in other activities typical of a public forum. . . ."

The California Constitution does protect your free-speech rights in privately owned shopping centers—as long as your activity doesn’t interfere with the primary commercial purpose of the mall.

- - - End Quote

I don't think it's crazy to imagine that a web space that's universally used for people to sound off, and to post comments on others' contributions, could become recognized as a public space for First Amendment purposes. (IANAL)

[1] http://www.aclunc.org/issues/freedom_of_press_and_speech/rig...

Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by regularfry on Friday December 16, 2011 @03:45AM (#3360040)
The problem with that kind of contract is that it means YouTube can't take advantage of the DMCA provision which limits their liability to uploaders. You're right, it is interesting. Ball's in YouTube's court.
Re:UMG claims "right to block or remove" YouTube videos it d... by tsotha on Friday December 16, 2011 @02:14PM (#3361860)
I wonder why youtube would sign an agreement like that at all..

I'm guessing penalties for hosting copyrighted content are so severe they're trying to establish a legal trail to show they made every effort to comply with the law.