News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by wizeman on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:36PM (#33598716)
> > Staking is not a loan.

> Yes it is. You give your money over to another organization, and that organization promises a % yield / APY in return. You aren't allowed the money back until later.

> Its totally a bond.

But in a bond and in a loan you are not guaranteed to get your money back (or the yield), while in staking, you are always guaranteed to get it back because of the consensus rules, right?

So I don't think it's the same thing, as in staking there is no such default risk because the staked coins remain yours [0] (with cryptographic assurance) and the yield is financed by currency inflation, which is guaranteed to happen (assuming there are no major bugs in the consensus rules, and that Coinbase and Binance don't become malicious and try to cheat the rules and get penalized for doing so).

[0] Well, technically they belong to Coinbase / Binance at that time, because they are the holders of the cryptographic keys.

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by dragontamer on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:40PM (#33598793)
You're guaranteed to get your money back from an Overnight loan to the Fed. (literally a 1-day loan to the USA's central bank).

This "risk free rate" serves as the basis of the theory behind our entire banking system. The fact that Ethereum decided to recreate this under separate principles is somewhat amusing, but its just that. A recreation of what we're already familiar with in the financial world.

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by wizeman on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:50PM (#33598934)
> You're guaranteed to get your money back from an Overnight loan to the Fed. (literally a 1-day loan to the USA's central bank).

Well, then those loans are also risk-free, right? Because they are also financed by increasing the money supply and the Fed can't spend the money that was loaned to them.

But normal loans and bonds are not risk-free, they have a default risk. Which is the entire reason why when you loan your money, sometimes you can't get it back.

Staking, however, is risk-free, so the following statements of yours are wrong.

> Everyone in the cryptocoin world is doing this "staking" == crappy loans / bonds business.

> > Staking is not a loan.

> Yes it is. You give your money over to another organization, and that organization promises a % yield / APY in return. You aren't allowed the money back until later.

> Its totally a bond.

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by dibt on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:00PM (#33599098)
I think the confusion is that they believe the token that is staked is a sunk cost, the same way a business would spend the money from a loan. Like you said, the token will be returned when unstaked.

If I take a loan out to buy and run a pizza restaurant, I can't just give the principal back if it fails. I would have to liquidate the business, which would not be equivalent to the starting capital costs.

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by dragontamer on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:02PM (#33599121)
The Fed always can return the money, because they control how much money is printed. Therefore, the money loaned to the Fed through the overnight rate is risk-free. That's why its called the risk-free rate.

It may only be a singular day worth of bond / IOU, but its still a loan/bond/debt instrument.

-------

Similarly, the Ethereum rewards are printed out of thin air, are they not? By the Ethereum staking system? Its not like the Ethereum they print existed beforehand.

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by dragontamer on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:55PM (#33599014)
Frankly, I see no contradiction, with what I said in any of my posts. Could you lay out more clearly where you think a contradiction has occurred?
Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by wizeman on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:12PM (#33599289)
> Frankly, I see no contradiction, with what I said in any of my posts. Could you lay out more clearly where you think a contradiction has occurred?

Sure. You said (in the context of talking about Binance and Coinbase):

> Everyone in the cryptocoin world is doing this "staking" == crappy loans / bonds business.

This phrase, in the context of the news we're discussing (about suspending withdrawals), implies that Coinbase and Binance are also incurring in a risk of suspending withdrawals because they might run out of liquidity due to staking (which you said is equivalent to a "crappy loans / bonds business").

However, staking is not equivalent to a "crappy loans / bonds business".

To argue that point, someone said that "Staking is not a loan", implying that unlike loans you can't lose money because of staking, but you said "it's totally a bond" because, I suppose, you're not allowed to get the money back until a certain time.

However, I think that you are missing the fact that unlike with loans and bonds, there is no risk of running out of liquidity because of staking.

If Coinbase and Binance were operating a real loans and bonds business (like banks do), and suddenly all customers demanded their deposits back, these exchanges couldn't force the borrowers to pay back their loans/bonds immediately so that they could fulfill the withdrawal demand. Not to mention that if the borrowers went bankrupt, the money would be lost, which would lead to Coinbase and Binance potentially losing customer funds, also becoming bankrupt and suspending withdrawals. This is more or less what is happening with some of these exchanges, because they seem to be gambling with customer funds.

But I think in staking it's completely different, because, as I argued, in staking there is no risk that borrowers go bankrupt and default on the loan/bond, as there are no borrowers. Instead, the yield is financed through inflation and the staked coins remain your property throughout the whole staking process -- nobody can spend them, so there is no risk that they can't be payed back.

And on top of that, customers aren't allowed to withdraw the staked amount until the staking expires, so there is no risk that Coinbase and Binance can't fulfill withdrawals because of staking.

Which means there is no risk of running out of liquidity because of staking.

Well, that's my understanding at least, but I'm sure I may be missing some points as I'm not actually an expert (or anything close to it) on staking.

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by dragontamer on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:45PM (#33599832)
> real loans and bonds business

You mean, like a Money Market fund like VMFXX?

https://investor.vanguard.com/investment-products/mutual-fun...

VMFXX has federal regulations, where it is _required_ to prove your liquidity reserves _DAILY_. EVERY SINGLE DAY, VMFXX publishes how much money they have that can be satisfied within 1-day, 1-week, and other such benchmarks.

The entire publication is available online, every single day, not only from VMFXX, but also all of VMFXX's competitors (such as SWVXX).

https://www.schwabassetmanagement.com/products/swvxx

----------

What Coinbase / Binance is doing is "Crappy" because their reporting guidelines are so much worse than what "the real banks" are doing. There's no one checking or double-checking these reserves.

Every single dollar (and even penny) is tracked in a money market fund. The _EXACT_ makeup of the loans is also tracked. The rules for how a "bank run" would be handled, are regulated and stated in advance. Everything has been planned out, discussed, debated, in Congress over-and-over again for the past 100 years as our laws have evolved.

VMFXX handles over $200 Billion of assets, and has been doing so for decades, in a tradition that follows US legal rules for nearly a hundred years (established since the times when the banks did lose a lot of money: back in the Great Depression). Its battle tested, pragmatic, and cheap (0.11% fees/year), extremely transparent, well regulated, well understood.

The comparison to Coinbase and Binance is laughable. There's no regulations, they haven't even been around for a decade, Binance isn't even being checked by anybody (being an offshore accounts), though I admit that Coinbase is at least in the USA and subject to US Law. But even Coinbase's reports on their assets pales in comparison to the information I get from VMFXX's pages.

-------

I'm trying to show you what a "real bank" does, such as VMFXX / Vanguard, with their "equivalent stablecoins" (aka, money market fund).

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by wizeman on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:55PM (#33599999)
> > real loans and bonds business

> You mean, like a Money Market fund like VMFXX?

No, I mean like when a bank buys government bonds, company bonds, or loans money to customers and businesses.

That's the kind of business that leads to bankruptcy if all your customers suddenly ask for their money back (which you have been lending behind their backs).

> What Coinbase / Binance is doing is "Crappy" because their reporting guidelines are so much worse than what "the real banks" are doing. There's no one checking or double-checking these reserves.

I'm not sure if that's the case, but if it is, then I agree with you.

Crypto exchanges should be the subject of periodic financial audits by reputable firms and as far as I know, some of the more reputable ones are already moving in that direction out of their own free will (to assure customers that are getting worried by their less reputable competitors that are now going bankrupt), even going so far as publishing cryptographic Merkle proofs of crypto reserves (but traditional financial audits are also necessary).

> Every single dollar (and even penny) is tracked in a money market fund. The _EXACT_ makeup of the loans is also tracked. The rules for how a "bank run" would be handled, are regulated and stated in advance. Everything has been planned out, discussed, debated, in Congress over-and-over again for the past 100 years as our laws have evolved.

It doesn't matter, bank runs can still happen when you're in the crappy loans and bonds business.

And when they do, nowadays not only banks get rewarded with government bailouts, but it's always the tax payer that ends up paying the bill, even though those tax payers are not responsible for the bank's risky and immoral (due to lack of customer consent) money managing policies. And the vast majority of those tax payers are not even customers of the bank!

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by dragontamer on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:07PM (#33600195)
> No, I mean like when a bank buys government bonds, company bonds, or loans money to customers and businesses.

Did you see the asset sheets on VMFXX? Its all government bonds, loans, and so forth. There's no "cash" just sitting there. Its all, completely composed of various kinds of loans (averaging 11-days in maturity).

I've given you a "real bank" (Vanguard, an investment bank specifically but yes, a bank), that's conducting these "loans" / bonds that you're talking about.

I've also brought up SWVXX, Schwab's competitor fund, is a "prime" MMF that consists _mostly_ of commecial paper (ie: loans to non-government entities), with higher levels of risk involved.

--------

Based on how this discussion is going, perhaps I should focus on SWVXX instead.

http://hosted.rightprospectus.com/SF/MMD/Fund.aspx?cu=808515...

There's even "less cash" here than in VMFXX. That's why I'm talking about these money-market funds. These are... the things you're trying to talk about, right? These banks / entities that are making a ton of loans / bonds to each other?

I'm thinking of real-world entities and trying to match them up to what you're talking about. These things have names ya know. They're not just mysterious "banks" out there. People invest into SWVXX or VMFXX, or other such tickers / funds.

> Weighted Average Maturity: 9 days

You see that? It will take 9 days for most of those funds to mature and turn into cash, on the average for SWVXX today. This isn't "cash", its a pile of loans. Very short-term high-quality loans, but its a pile of loans. Is this not what you were trying to talk about?

> That's the kind of business that leads to bankruptcy if all your customers suddenly ask for their money back (which you have been lending behind their backs).

Yes. That's why there's strict liquidity tests, liquidity reserves, and publication requirements for entities such as SWVXX. The risk is real, and we need to keep an eye on it to make sure that Schwab and Vanguard aren't cheating the books.

Those publication requirements simply do not exist for Binance or Coinbase. There's no asset sheet vs liabilities sheets. There's no reporting guidelines. There's nothing.

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by wizeman on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:14PM (#33600291)
> I've given you a "real bank" (Vanguard, an investment bank specifically but yes, a bank), that's conducting these "loans" / bonds that you're talking about.

Investment banks are not problematic because the customer is the one who decides how much and where their money is getting invested (therefore he knows how much he is risking, and how it is getting risked).

This is unlike what happens with traditional banks, which is what I was referring to when talking about the crappy loans and bonds business (and lending the customer's funds behind their backs, even if the customer is aware of it and does not consent).

> Those publication requirements simply do not exist for Binance or Coinbase. There's no asset sheet vs liabilities sheets. There's no reporting guidelines. There's nothing.

If that's the case, then I agree, this should change. I would prefer if exchanges themselves would do this and customers would verify this, but even though I'm a libertarian, I wouldn't object to the government requiring reasonable, periodic financial audits of crypto exchanges by reputable financial audit firms because I am in favor of complete transparency[0] (be it regarding government or companies) and I recognize that too many bad apples are entering the crypto business and ruining its reputation (and customers of crypto exchanges are obviously not doing sufficient due diligence).

[0] More transparency can greatly increase the benefits of market-based capitalism, because it works more efficiently (i.e. market participants make better decisions and get more value out of it) when the participants are acting with more information than when they are acting with less information.

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by dragontamer on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:21PM (#33600419)
> Investment banks are not problematic because the customer is the one who decides how much and where their money is getting invested (therefore he knows how much he is risking, and how it is getting risked).

Do... you know what a MMF is? (money market fund)

A MMF is a federally regulated investment product where 1-share equals $1. Investors invest into MMFs because they are "safe", and have a huge amount of federal regulations to almost-guarantee the 1-share == $1 price point. (but not "totally" guarantee). Small levels of risk are acceptable.

Yes, they're offered by investment banks rather than traditional banks. But the "fundamental trust" that 1-share in VMFXX == $1 is extremely deep.

That's why I keep bringing up this comparison. MMFs are allowed to loan out their money and partake in various investment schemes to generate a yield. HOWEVER, there's reporting requirements, there's investment requirements, there's rating requirements, there's transparency, etc. etc.

All of this giant exercise with crytocoins trying to "make a stablecoin", where 1-stablecoin == $1 all the time is just a crazy scheme to recreate MMFs. That's my overall point and viewpoint.

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by wizeman on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:32PM (#33600571)
> That's why I keep bringing up this comparison. MMFs are allowed to loan out their money and partake in various investment schemes to generate a yield. HOWEVER, there's reporting requirements, there's investment requirements, there's rating requirements, there's transparency, etc. etc.

I think that's a good thing, although there are 2 things I disagree with:

1) I believe the investment requirements are a scheme that is unfair and can lead to forced (and unnatural) inequality.

I would replace this with (sufficiently strict) tests of investment knowledge for new investors.

2) In practice the ratings agencies have a less than stellar record, as the way they are set up, they have an inherent conflict of interest. This leads to a false sense of security.

So I would just get rid of these, but I don't see anything wrong with the rest in general (I'm sure there would be some specifics I would disagree with).

> All of this giant exercise with crytocoins trying to "make a stablecoin", where 1-stablecoin == $1 all the time is just a crazy scheme to recreate MMFs. That's my overall point and viewpoint.

It's quite different, as stablecoins can be traded in a completely decentralized way (i.e. peer-to-peer) with blockchain protocols using cryptographic assurances.

But yes, in theory an MMF-backed stablecoin could be traded on a blockchain, and I see nothing wrong with that. That said, an MMF-backed stablecoin would be a bit more risky than a USD-backed stablecoin, due to an MMF being inherently a bit more risky than the USD.

However, yeah.. another point is that the companies that issue stablecoins are also quite far from being sufficiently transparent. They also need to be subject to the same periodic financial audit requirements by a reputable firm as a crypto exchange should!

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by dragontamer on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:38PM (#33600651)
USDC doesn't keep its USD in "cash". Its claiming its got "commercial paper" backing it. ("Commercial paper" being a codeword for loans, the same 5-day / 9-day loans that make up an entity such as SWVXX). Or government loans, etc. etc. Its the same thing, but worse.

Its no more secure than an MMF as it is. In fact, due to the much weaker reporting guidelines, USDC is likely worse than an MMF like SWVXX.

No stablecoin promises "cash" holdings. Literally none. The best you've got in the cryptocoin world is MMF-like promises, except without any of the MMF regulations.

-------

There's no guarantees that USDC's backing of "commercial paper" has any good rating at all. What 5-day loans are USDC banking on? Is it Bank of America? Or is it a loan to Binance? No one knows.

> USDC has always been backed by the equivalent value of U.S. dollar denominated assets; USDC reserves are kept in the management and custody of leading U.S. financial institutions, including BlackRock and Bank of New York Mellon

Re:BlockFi crypto exchange pauses withdrawals citing FTX/Ala... by wizeman on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:49PM (#33600797)
Yeah, I know... what these companies are doing is absolute crap and I suspect that in the future this is going to lead to an even bigger crisis than what's happening right now in the crypto industry.

I suspect that this is a side effect of 1) being impossible to store large amounts of USD cash in a bank, at least without incurring into significant risks of losing it or actually even losing money over time due to negative interest rates and/or 2) being more lucrative to hold these paper products rather than keep everything strictly in cash, perhaps even also 3) lack of moral standards? I don't know.

I think this is even worse than what the traditional banks are doing and I'm completely against it. Especially due to the lack of transparency that you are mentioning.