The short seller also mentions that this is only “3%” of what he has and is working with an investigative journalist to blow this up. And that was weeks ago, and they were probably working on it before that.
It’s not about credentials. It’s that you have 20 year olds out of nowhere suddenly managing tens of billions of dollars. Like the guy says, it doesn’t make any sense.
In interviews, FTX never gave reasons of why they moved to the Bahamas from Hong Kong. He really doesn’t ever explain anything.
It works for him the same way it works for Neil Gershenfeld. Be palatably erratic, assume the mad scientist role, make your credentials known, and people will eventually start to treat you as though you are brilliant.
That schtick hits more than one of Cialdini's six principles of persuasion.
(NB this is not a comparison of Gershenfeld and Bankman-Fried, just an observation of what seems like one shared attribute.)
Ok, sure, when he's ready to present that let's discuss it. Until then it's nothing. But what's the point of doing an interview and saying "I've got good info but I'm not going to share it until later"
I think one searches for darker answers because the likely answer, that everyone was duped by these people in normal ways and there’s not some deeper connection, is a far more disturbing prospect.
Now I actually think that although this take is realistic, it is actually overly cynical and actually underestimates the possibility of disruption in finance. In actuality, not knowing the complexity allows a young entrepreneur to develop a simplistic plan and pitch it with conviction to VCs who also don't know any better. The mistake experienced people are making is that their experience tells them it is only reasonable to do a thing "correctly" or "scalably" when in fact the incorrect, illegal, unscalable way wins you valuable proof points. And with enough proof points and follow-on VC rounds the simplistic plan can mature enough to actually become functional.
In the specific case of SBF and FTX, I do think the critic's seemingly superficial cynicism was actually both well-founded and ultimately correct. Launching an exchange functionally, legally and scalably was in fact too much for the inexperienced leadership of the business. They tried really hard to make a business model that worked and scaled fast. But in doing so, they ended up with effectively designing a circular reference (trading their own token) which made a lot of money for a while, but ended up crashing their business. I think they were well-intentioned, but it is true that more experienced leadership would not have tried the self-referential growth strategies FTX/Alameda engaged in. And in retrospect the critic's spidey sense was right; the pace of growth of FTX was bizarrely unsustainable and likely pointed to an underlying system that didn't make sense.
Molly White's most recent article on the collapse was posted on HN just yesterday.
This is highly irregular and a potential indicator of a scam on the backs of retail investors.
2) He noted the chief regulatory officer of FTX, Dan Friedberg, was the general counsel for a poker site that defrauded its players.
A big red flag for anyone thinking of interacting with FTX in any way.
3) SBF has a record of deploying capital poorly (making losing investments and falling for scams) and he provided no good rationale for making these bad bets
A clear sign he isn't a good businessman and it creates even more skepticism that FTX could be viable.
4) He sees through their obvious attempts to paint a rosy picture of SBF and FTX with their very vague but positive marketing, but no ability to explain concretely what is positive about FTX, what their business model is (why the founders are getting so rich!)
These things are "smelly". They are like "code smells". On their own, they don't necessarily indicate anything, but taken together they could be an indication of much deeper problems with the codebase.
Marc was saying that the microscope needed to be put on FTX, SBF, and Gary Wang ASAP, because things stunk to high heaven. He was saying questions needed to be answered and the fact they were seemingly purposely being evaded was a big red flag to him.
He simply said he doesn't know where it came from. That doesn't mean it didn't come from anywhere. If he'd actually taken the time to flesh any of this out then it could have been useful but as it stands, it wasn't
His criticism seems to break down to:
1) Look at him, he's ugly
2) He doesn't have the proper lineage of insider mentors to be allowed to be a billionaire
3) We don't have the full story on the original arbitrage mixed in with some political pandering
4) The compliance officer was sketchy
4 seems to be the only valid point. 3 is worth further research but not really anything in itself. The other 2 reflect more poorly on this guy than SBF. Overall, I don't think this guy really had anything, I think he just didn't like the smell and ended up getting lucky on the timing.
But he 100% did not call out any meaningful elements of what ended up happening in any detail.