Pretty normal for a patio11 post.
Anyways, this is all very subjective and based on personal preference so it's probably not useful so I'll shut up now.
I appreciate that patio11 states things that might seem obvious to someone knowledgeable in a field. It reminds me of [WP:Obvious] from back when I started using Wikipedia. It states:
> State facts that may be obvious to you, but are not necessarily obvious to the reader. Usually, such a statement will be in the first sentence or two of the article.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Writing_better_artic...
This is such a difficult thing to do "correctly" because there is a danger as you see on the wikipedia link that you might start stating that the sky is blue. (Meta: Did I just do that?) This is what patio11 does so well.
I mean this is pretty early on in the article:
> Every business has a balance sheet, which contrasts its assets (valuable things it owns) against liabilities (valuable things it owes to other people). The difference between assets and liabilities is equity.
> Financial businesses will frequently have non-financial assets and liabilities. Ignore those for the sake of simplicity. Ignore the nice building, the computers, the payroll due on Friday for work which has already been completed. Focus just on the financial assets and liabilities, things like “mortgages our bank owns” (asset) and “deposits from customers” (liability).
> Leverage is the ratio of your liabilities to your equity. Simple division. Fourth grade math. If you have $110 million in assets and $100 million in liabilities you, by subtraction, have $10 million in equity against your $100 million in liabilities. You are said to be levered 10:1.
Now if I were to edit this, I'd probably go off a tangent at this point. I would say something silly like You have deposits from customers worth USD 100M. You loaned out USD 110M.
What happens if, of the people you loaned your money to, half of them disappear with your money? Now, your assets are only USD 65M. However, your liabilities are still USD 100M. Your equity is USD 65M - USD 100M = a negative USD 35M! You are properly screwed.
In fact, you'd be screwed if your loans soured by anything greater than your equity of USD 10M, let say USD 11M. Lets say your borrowers are unable to repay you any more than USD 99M of the USD 110 they owe you. Your equity is USD 99M - USD 100M = - USD 1M.
What just happened? I took you, the unsuspecting reader, on my boat and threw you out in the middle of the ocean. I've done you a disservice. Did you expect to read that tangent after the quote I had from patio11? Probably not. Did you expect to see a concept like negative equity and negative leverage if you're just learning about leverage? Unlikely.
In any case, the fact that I feel dissatisfied just writing this comment is a testament to just how difficult it is to explain something. Even when the concept I am trying to explain is nothing more than "it is difficult to explain something in brief".
"The world of finance hails the invention of the wheel over and over again, often in a slightly more unstable version. All financial innovation involves in one form or another, the creation of debt secured in greater or lesser adequacy by real assets."
In the 2008 financial crisis, some have paraphrased this as "All financial innovation is leverage dressed up as something different."
But that then begs the question, what happens if the custodian goes bust? Well custodians also have a custodian, diversifying the risk one step further (but not completely). Custodian inception!
Further on this here:
https://moneykingnz.com/what-happens-to-your-money-if-invest...
Sure it's true at some level but not a useful distinction if you're a customer or vendor.
The basic underlying principle of a product/service should be communicable and relatively universal. The details are of how it's tailored to your specific situation should come with cons and unknowns in other situations.
If it's not communicable and/or sounds like there are no cons they're not being honest about what it is (intentionally or unintentionally).
You have $100 worth of stock in Google. You think Google stock is going to appreciate so you borrow $50 of my money to buy more stock. I see that you have $100 worth of Google stock which provides me with some security that you have a valuable asset and are a worthwhile borrower.
But, instead of Google's stock value increasing it starts to fall. You took my money and I'm getting nervous so I force you to sell your Google stock. At one point you had $150 worth of Google stock but now I've forced you to sell your stock for a total of $75 which allows me to recoup my lent money ($50) plus my fees and I really don't care how much money you are left with, if any.
This is important for the economy because credit (which this is) helps create growth and drives economies - when credit is tight then economies grow slowly if at all.
You had 100 dollars, you're leveraging 50 cents for every dollar you put in giving you a .5:1 leverage ( or 50%, or 1.5/1 as a fraction)
Only if the stock loses more than 100 dollars in your equity would the broker be worried and ask for margin. This means your $150 dollars of leveraged stock would have to drop to $50 dollars before the broker would be worried and sell your stock to get their $50 back. This means your stock could drop 66,7% or 2/3 as a fraction.
All fees are paid upfront and the rest from your margin. Not your stock.
I think an easy example nearly anyone can understand is their mortgage. You put down $50k for a $500k house. The house goes up just 10% to $550k, if you sell you've doubled your money after repaying the $450k you've borrowed. Of course, if the price goes down 10%, you're completely wiped out.
Amazing how time flies. I'm pretty sure anyone who was old enough to own a home in 2007/2008 in a "hot" market knows exactly how mortgage leverage can work on the downside.
Sorta... Usually when people talk about that, it's mostly in the context of balloon payments and variable rate mortgages where the value of your house dropping coincided with sudden increases to your monthly mortgage payment or large bills coming due.
Well that's the problem isn't it?
1. Bank A offers you 5% interest for a 1 year deposit. You deposit $100 of your own money. You are unlevered. Things go well and after a year you receive $105, a neat 5% return on your investment. Or things don't go well, bank A turns out to be a scam and you receive $0, a -100% return.
2. Bank B offers you a loan for a year for 4% interest. You borrow $900, together with your own $100 you deposit $1000 at bank A. You are levered 1:9. Things go well and after a year you receive $1050 ($1000+5% interest) from bank A, you repay bank B $936 ($900 + 4% interest), so you're left with $114, a very neat 14% return (almost triple the unlevered return). Or things don't go well, bank A turns out to be a scam and you receive $0. But now you still owe bank B $936, so together with your own $100 loss you made a -1036% return. Oops.
p.s. It's called leverage because (like a physical lever that allows you to lift something much heavier than without) supplementing your own funds with lots of borrowed money allows you to tackle something much bigger than using only your own money, like buying a house or starting a business or getting 5% on $1000 instead of on $100.