News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Whisper list’ contains 40 politicians never to accept a ... by asoneth on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:41AM (#33561366)
In addition to the other answers given:

If a name is erroneously omitted from the list then a subsequent incident would presumably re-add the offender.

If a name is incorrectly included on the list (accidentally or maliciously) then there could be a decay function if reports include a timeframe and/or confidence level. For example, if the last report of bad behavior was third-hand and years ago and no one has heard corroborating reports since then then individuals may choose to de-prioritize or drop the name from the lists they transmit.

But it's also begging the question -- the list may not be resistant to transmission errors and yet may still provide value to the people using it.

Re:‘Whisper list’ contains 40 politicians never to accept a ... by upsidesinclude on Friday November 11, 2022 @10:00AM (#33561604)
Or not at all. The list serves to alienate certain people and prevent them from becoming competitive or developing networks.

The negatives of this kind of behavior are equal to the supposed benefits

Re:‘Whisper list’ contains 40 politicians never to accept a ... by asoneth on Friday November 11, 2022 @11:42AM (#33563034)
> Or not at all

If the list is not at all accurate I doubt it would propagate as well or as long because an entirely inaccurate list provides negative value to its recipients by giving them a false sense of security that will be eventually dispelled when they realize their personal experience does not correlate with the list. I would be more concerned about a list that is sufficiently accurate to ensure continued propagation while still containing harmful inaccuracies.

> The negatives of this kind of behavior are equal to the supposed benefits

Whether the harm caused by inaccurate warnings exceeds the harm avoided by the accurate warnings seems subjective because these harms are different and impact different people. It would also be hard to assess without knowing the actual ratio of accurate to inaccurate warnings.

But regardless of whether these kinds of lists cause net harm overall, individuals will continue to share warnings as long as doing so provides net value to them. Outlawing rumors is something not even totalitarian regimes have managed to do, so the only solution I can think of would be to ensure that the alternate methods of addressing problematic behavior are more attractive to people than resorting to rumors.