News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do I Look Like a CEO? by nostrademons on Friday October 17, 2008 @09:16AM (#335562)
> The idea that people will continue to upload the file after they have downloaded it seemed silly before someone actually did it.

This part had been well-validated before BitTorrent came out. People were already using Napster, Kazaa, and AudioGalaxy, all of which relied on people leaving files available for upload after they finished downloading them.

Using an HTTP tracker was a pretty courageous act though, and I don't think the rest of the protocol would work without it. At the time, everyone was doing desktop clients and trying to make things as anonymous as possible, since they were all afraid of copyright-infringement lawsuits.

I kinda wonder whether Bram really didn't know it would be used for copyright infringement, or if he just says that because he's smart enough not to get sued. Every other P2P filesharing system was used to share music, and the mainstream media was going on and on about how Napster was the death of the music industry. You'd have to be living under a rock not to make that connection.

Re:Do I Look Like a CEO? by DenisM on Friday October 17, 2008 @11:55AM (#335702)
That's nothing, every operating system was used for copyright infrighment too! Bill Gates has clearly contemplated mass-scale music downloading when creating windows, unless he was living under the rock.

Sarcasm aside, universal tools are like that - people use them for many things.

Re:Do I Look Like a CEO? by nostrademons on Friday October 17, 2008 @12:43PM (#335759)
My curiosity is because every other P2P filesharing tool written before BitTorrent was used for copyright infringement. Bill Gates is a different situation, because there were no PCs before he wrote Altair Basic. There were plenty of P2P filesharing services before BitTorrent, though.

You can't predict the future, but you ought to have a pretty good idea what's happening in the present.

Re:Do I Look Like a CEO? by maxklein on Friday October 17, 2008 @12:11PM (#335723)
Yes, but there was no client when Bram did it. It was a download window like in a browser.
Re:Do I Look Like a CEO? by nostrademons on Friday October 17, 2008 @12:39PM (#335754)
Same goes for Audiogalaxy. (Doesn't AudioGalaxy's founder occasionally show up on this board?) It was a web page where you could see what music people were sharing, search for it, and then download it. When you downloaded a file, it would download a small stub (via the browser's mechanism), which would then be opened by the AudioGalaxy service on the client, which would queue up the file for later downloading.

I remember arriving at college, where each person had their own pet ways of downloading MP3s. Within a week, my whole dorm had basically standardized on AudioGalaxy.

Re:Do I Look Like a CEO? by qqq on Friday October 17, 2008 @11:38AM (#335678)
with kazaa/etc, you share all the files in your library. so if i download one, then unless i remove it from the library folder i share it every time i download anything. so it's kinda different. bittorrent doesn't share old stuff.