News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by seydor on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:52AM (#33547288)
> Without jobs that can be lost or wives and children who could suffer, young, unmarried, unemployed men are poised to cause or be recruited to cause social and political trouble, Basu said. On the other hand, she said, “young women getting more educated and marrying later may yet turn out to be the harbingers of the modernization and social change in the country that seems to be otherwise slow in coming.”

Sounds like marriage is modern slavery for both

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by Icathian on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:00AM (#33547412)
I think this is an incredibly uncharitable take.

I have a wife and kid. I have more to lose, sure, but I also have lots to gain. My friends and family who are single and childless have less of both (according to them, I'm not trying to pass any judgment here).

That's a tradeoff that is up to everyone to make for themselves, but characterizing this voluntary life path as "slavery" is disingenuous and misleading at best.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by capybara_2020 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:40AM (#33548032)
I am curious what do you have to gain compared to single people?
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by Icathian on Thursday November 10, 2022 @01:01PM (#33550526)
I find great enjoyment and personal satisfaction in raising my child, and building a life together with my wife.

It's difficult to articulate, but I usually phrase it as something along these lines.

* As a child, relatively small things bring you true joy. Opening a toy, playing games with friends, lots of stuff. And the real version of joy, where your heart feels too big for your chest.

* After about age 20 or so, I noticed those moments becoming less and less frequent. It took more and more to grant them, things like kissing my wife for the first time, day of my marriage, etc.

* Raising my child seems to have reset this. I feel true and genuine joy almost every day, just interacting with them. It's like being a kid again, for me.

* I believe that raising my child without my wife would not be the same experience, and probably would not give me the happiness I have now. She has expressed all of this to me as well.

That is what my current life path offers me that a hypothetical single me would not have had, and it means an awful lot to me. This is obviously not going to be true for everyone, but I also don't imagine I'm the only one who feels this way. The above is almost a cliche, it's voiced so often.

Obviously there are also tons of stats about life expectancy, average earnings, and other such economic and practical metrics being better for married men in the USA. Those are probably true to a degree, but don't resonate with me the same way. Plus, this being HN, I imagine a lot of us would be fine either way.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by 888666 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:07AM (#33547535)
It's not voluntary for many people in India.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by seydor on Thursday November 10, 2022 @11:49AM (#33549278)
it's not my take, but the article makes it sound like marriage is severely holding back people and that indian men are naturally inclined to riot. all of which is BS of course
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by goodpoint on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:55AM (#33547344)
Unsurprisingly it's becoming unpopular across the world...

Of all places, India has a very long history of arranged/forced marriages. That's a gross human right violation.

The article is so biased that it even starts with "Marriage is highly revered".

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by goodpoint on Thursday November 10, 2022 @07:23PM (#33555732)
Interesting, a rain of silent downvotes...