News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:35AM (#33547022)
> Although more unmarried men could stir up political trouble

I always find something a little dark about this argument against letting men be single, and against practices like polygamy with some men having multiple wives and others not having wives.

There's a kind of 'or else...' vibe to it. As if some people think it's women's job to marry men to stop them being a menace to society.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by jollyllama on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:42AM (#33547130)
It reduces men's families to hostages; it implies married men don't make trouble because they're afraid of what will be done to their families.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by AustinDev on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:50AM (#33547260)
The US military takes this sort of thing into consideration for security clearances. You’re much less likely to sell state secrets if you have a family at home.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by polishdude20 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:55AM (#33547341)
In a way even thinking about this when it comes to world leaders I would much rather all world leaders have rich family lives so that they can think about their families before they do anything stupid.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by if_by_whisky on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:09AM (#33547572)
I think it's more about what the opportunity cost is to their families.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by gjsman-1000 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:43AM (#33547139)
I don't like it either - but if history has taught us anything, angry young men are a common source of social revolution. Often because they have nothing to lose - and if they hate the system holding them down, tearing it down is fun revenge.

I'm at the point where I don't like it, but it is probably true regardless.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by ajsnigrutin on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:57AM (#33547377)
But is this actually bad?

I'm not that familliar with situation in india, but in "the west", we've come to situations where young people (with a very wide definition of "young") are unable to afford homes (and in turn, kids), are underpaid, and in some of those countries (mostly usa) cannot even afford education and healthcare (in contrast to eg. europe, where education is taxpayer paid but healthcare is slowly going down lower and lower).

Maybe it is the time to say "stop", we want homes, better pay (and all the other stuff), and such major changes only come with enough people who are fed up and have nothing else to lose... so yes, young, childless, unmarried men.

I know most revolutions end badly, but find me a developed "western" place with affordable housing?

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by gjsman-1000 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:01AM (#33547426)
In my own personal opinion, entertainment, cohabitation (comparatively easy, low-risk, few obligations sex compared to historically), and alcohol/drugs are the only things keeping young men from getting violent.

If it were not for these things, I believe that we would be much closer to revolution even if nobody can see it yet. Potentially Tzarist Russia or Weimar Germany close. I think young men have all the social indicators needed to cause them to broadly revolt; we just have some placating methods that didn't exist historically.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by ajsnigrutin on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:11AM (#33547602)
The problem I see is, that those people are not the "80s movies bachelors" (with enough money, flashy clothes, nice houses and cars.. and well, drugs and sex), but people literally living on the edge of their financial capabilites, sharing 3 bedroom apartments with 5 more people, barely able to afford the rent and bills, and pretty much everything left over is going for entertainment (drug and sex). With the coming financial crisis (caused again by dick-measuring politicians) a rise in eg power and heat bills with already overinflated rents and layoffs will cause more and more people to basically "not-lose-anything" if they actually get violent.

Sadly, the governments solve this by taxing the "rich" (=middle class, because the actual rich always avoid the taxes, and engineers, coders, tradesmen etc. are the one who get fucked), bringing everyone (except the actual rich) to some low minimum needed to survive while still being fucked in every other sense. So yeah... the only way this can be solved is (in my, controversial opinion), is for people to actually get angry and replace the whole set of politicians and people in bed with them.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by luckylion on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:52AM (#33547298)
> As if some people think it's women's job to marry men to stop them being a menace to society.

The same argument is made for wealth transfers via taxes: pay up, or they might just take it, and it's cheaper and more efficient to codify wealth transfer instead of just letting it happen.

And you don't necessarily need men to get married to not be trouble makers. But you'll need them to have something to do. If that's not marriage, education or work, you better have entertainment or drugs available.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by jonahx on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:54AM (#33547322)
> There's a kind of 'or else...' vibe to it. As if some people think it's women's job to marry men to stop them being a menace to society.

I don't think anyone studying this seriously is making that argument or even trying to slyly imply it.

I think it breaks down like this:

We know "lots of single men" correlates with many indicators that are, broadly, "bad for society".

What is driving this change? What can we about it? The "what can we do about it?" is focused, again broadly, on "fixing men" or "fixing the incentives for men" or "fixing the opportunities for men."

No one is proposing, "Hey women, you better start marrying these unattractive layabouts or else society will collapse and you'll be living in dystopia...".

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:56AM (#33547368)
I'm sure I've read it in reputable newspapers presented as an argument for keeping consenting polygamous relationships illegal - 'all the high status men will get multiple wives and low status men won't have wives and will be troublemakers'.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by jonahx on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:06AM (#33547522)
Yes, that is true, but even that argument does not imply that "women should be forced to marry men they don't like." To make that jump is to make a straw man of the argument. Whether or not that is factually true about polygamous society, I have no idea (EDIT: looks like it is, according to the other comments). I'm saying only that "being against legal polygamy" does not mean "being for forced marriages."
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:59AM (#33548344)
It is saying that you may not be able to marry the person that you do actually want to marry though, and the justification given by some people is that is so that you are incentivised instead marry someone else, someone you presumably did not really want to marry.

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/07/case-ag...

> monogamy's main cultural evolutionary advantage over polygyny is the more egalitarian distribution of women, which reduces male competition and social problems.

It's this 'distribution of women' that seems dark to me. That can't be that much of a crazy opinion as people here seem to think?

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by jonahx on Thursday November 10, 2022 @11:25AM (#33548843)
> It's this 'distribution of women' that seems dark to me. That can't be that much of a crazy opinion as people here seem to think?

It's a very analytical, "cold" way to phrase it, yes, but you get this effect with many "human" problems that are studied scientifically, whether poverty, starvation, etc. Also note the same researchers can, and do, refer to the 'distribution of men' when discussing female mating preferences.

> incentivised instead marry someone else, someone you presumably did not really want to marry.

At a macro level, this is obviously true statistically. But do people experience it as such? You live in a non-polygamous society -- do you or the women you know feel like their spouses were forced on them? Because, to some degree, statistically, they were, as you correctly point out. But the mechanism is just via an accepted, background social norm... there are no arranged marriages, all marriages all voluntary, and everyone retains the option not to marry.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @11:36AM (#33549050)
Yeah the theoretical situation is "I love X - can I marry him? No. Why not? Because he's already married and it's not good for the other men to not get a wife." and sounds shitty. I don't know how many people experience that in reality.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by jonahx on Thursday November 10, 2022 @12:01PM (#33549553)
But that is exactly the current system we have in the US and UK.

He can divorce and marry you, but that "frees up" his ex-wife to appease the roiling crowd of violent men. I'm being facetious, of course, because who thinks about it like that? No one. We just experience a cultural norm where people only marry one other person. And mostly no one complains.

And yet indirectly this norm has a macro statistical effect of keeping the peace.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @12:14PM (#33549777)
> But that is exactly the current system we have in the US and UK.

Yeah I know - that's the situation I'm talking about. I know nobody seems to complain in public but I guess there are people out there is applies to. Maybe one day it'll change and people will be free to marry who they want.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by jonahx on Thursday November 10, 2022 @12:43PM (#33550239)
> Maybe one day it'll change and people will be free to marry who they want.

People don't complain in private either. I've literally never heard it, even 2nd hand.

You're making it sound like a law against marrying someone of a difference race. It is nothing like that. Most Western women would be appalled at the idea of being someone's 3rd wife.

There is tiny subculture of poly-amorous people. Maybe some of them complain? But they can still be with who they want, just without the official seal.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by red_trumpet on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:06AM (#33547527)
> consenting polygamous relationships

Where are they illegal? Or are you talking about marriage?

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by jonahx on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:09AM (#33547563)
Yes, he's talking about men legally having multiple wives.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:14AM (#33547646)
Polygamy is illegal in the UK, US, and most places I believe?
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by gjsman-1000 on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:05AM (#33547500)
You can actually look into statistics and see this is true. The 20 most violent African countries, for example, almost all have widespread polygamy.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:06AM (#33547523)
Yeah I know it's true not questioning the fact... but is it women's job to solve it by marrying people they won't want to marry? Why should they do that to solve society's problems?
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by twoifbyseat on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:24AM (#33547792)
No. They don't really bear the brunt of the violence anyway, so why should they care?
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:40AM (#33548036)
I actually think women do bear the brunt of an unstable society.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by luckylion on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:25AM (#33547815)
They're not romantic choices, the polygamy follows power distribution. The actual problem isn't that it's legal to have multiple wives, it's that resources are distributed so badly, that you end up with lots of poor men not having a stake in society. They're expected to work so that the rich and their wives can live leisurely, but it's all stick and no carrot. If the stick every breaks, you get lots of violence.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by jonahx on Thursday November 10, 2022 @12:25PM (#33549951)
Worth noting that in countries with polygamy, it's not like women are afforded more choice than in their Western counterparts. Quite the contrary. The type of thing you see is a poor farmer marrying off his very young daughter as the 3rd wife of someone wealthy to provide for her. So in practice it's much closer to forced marriages, not unfettered choice for women.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by leereeves on Friday November 11, 2022 @02:40AM (#33558202)
Do you want a world where no one makes sacrifices to solve anyone else's problem?
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by P_I_Staker on Thursday November 10, 2022 @12:14PM (#33549771)
Seems like there could be some correlation issues here.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by safety1st on Thursday November 10, 2022 @09:56AM (#33547364)
I mean, there's academic work on this subject that's almost 30 years old:

https://www.wilsoncenter.org/event/young-men-and-war-could-w...

If you're aware of this work and you think it's flawed, why don't you elaborate? That could be a great discussion.

If you're accusing Wiener and Mesquida of being sexist, or if you think research on this subject should be suppressed, you should come out and say that.

What's your contribution exactly other than strawmanning "some people" as bigots?

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:00AM (#33547421)
Lol you're using a lot of incendiary words I didn't use there and then asking if I'm straw manning?
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by safety1st on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:08AM (#33547556)
> As if some people think it's women's job to marry men to stop them being a menace to society.

Why don't you elaborate on exactly who you were libeling here?

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:42AM (#33548060)
Nobody. You made up all those things you asked if I believed, out of thin air, for some bizarre reason. "If you're... If you're..." is a red flag for an argument. If you're not clear I was making an argument yourself... maybe it's because I didn't make it?
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by P_I_Staker on Thursday November 10, 2022 @12:15PM (#33549797)
Maybe you should calm down. OP is asking some fair and interesting questions. There's no need to be this defensive.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @12:21PM (#33549893)
I can't debate them to defend an opinion I don't hold and never presented!

The answer to all their questions is basically 'I never said that in the first place.'

How's that going to lead to an interesting discussion?

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by safety1st on Thursday November 10, 2022 @12:40PM (#33550192)
Your comment accused "some people" of being sexist. I asked you who those people are. There are specific academics who are proponents of this theory, so the most likely guess is that they were the target of your defamatory statement. I gave you the opportunity to clarify who you were defaming, but for some reason you don't want to. (In my opinion, you shouldn't be posting vague defamatory statements in the first place.)
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @12:42PM (#33550221)
> Your comment accused "some people" of being sexist.

I literally haven't used the word 'sexist' once in this entire thread. That's a word you used. See what I mean? I can't defend the use of 'sexist'... because I didn't use it... you did!

I've leave this thread to let you argue with your own choice of words on your own!

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by safety1st on Thursday November 10, 2022 @01:01PM (#33550539)
To quote you verbatim:

> some people think it's women's job to marry men to stop them being a menace to society.

So now you're saying this view held by these 'some people' isn't sexist?

I don't really have any desire to continue this, the fact is you posted a defamatory statement and don't want to own it, but I think to have posted it at all is against the spirit of Hacker News, which encourages open inquiry and curiosity, not attacking people for their immorality or whatever you were doing here. You should post that kind of thing on Reddit's r/politics instead where I'm sure people will upvote it like crazy. Have a nice day.

Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by ImprobableTruth on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:05AM (#33547501)
Is the argument that poverty causes crime 'dark'?
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by chrisseaton on Thursday November 10, 2022 @11:17AM (#33548686)
It's not the identification of the cause - it's the action taken based on it 'and therefore we will enact this law' - for example laws forbidding consenting people to marry if one of them already has a marriage.
Re:‘Young, male and aimless’: Why are men in India delaying ... by jmeister on Thursday November 10, 2022 @10:17AM (#33547687)