News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IodéOS Is Open Source by F3nd0 on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @07:45AM (#33530758)
I assume that implies you are not proponents of software freedom? The distinction may be important for some people, if only for placing trust in your long-term vision.
Re:IodéOS Is Open Source by capableweb on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @08:01AM (#33530953)
Maybe I'm missing something obvious, but how does open sourcing something imply they are not proponents of software freedom? For me, it would imply (or be rather explicit) that they are proponents of software freedom.
Re:IodéOS Is Open Source by tokai on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @08:57AM (#33531638)
Free software is all about user freedoms. Open source is about the source being open. It is two positions on access to software and code with different ideological foundations.
Re:IodéOS Is Open Source by capableweb on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:26AM (#33532028)
If the source was just published without any open source license, I'd call that "public code" or "code released", not specifically "open source" which comes with a different understanding than just the code being released under any specific open source license.

So if the goal is user freedom, how would open source limit that? You have the right to modify the software and you have the right to re-distribute it, together or without your own changes. What "user freedom" is missing from this?

Re:IodéOS Is Open Source by tokai on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @09:57AM (#33532459)
Why don't you look it up? Open Source was a reaction to the political implications of Free Software, that didn't float well with the private sector. The fault lines between the two are quite clear.
Re:IodéOS Is Open Source by capableweb on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @01:42PM (#33536019)
Why don't you reply with your opinion instead?

How fun would the HN comments be if we just refer people to other places, without actually referring to any specific things?

You're not actually refuting anything I say, just give some vague "go look it up"...

Re:IodéOS Is Open Source by F3nd0 on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @01:20PM (#33535716)
Open-sourcing something does not imply that at all, since open-sourcing almost always equals to releasing as free software. It's the choice to talk about the source now being open, as opposed to the users now being free, that reflects a different points of focus in the wider community, and tends to reflect one's motivations and point of view as well.

If you hold the firm belief that software users ought to be free, and that is your main motivation for releasing something as free software, you are likely to talk about it. If you give users freedom 'on accident' while opening up your source, whether it's because that's convenient for you, you think that's mutually beneficial, or you just choose whatever term seems the most popular since you don't have a belief of your own to base the choice on, it goes to show that users' freedom is not your primary concern. Now you might not necessarily think that's a bad thing, but if you do, it might be a good idea not to put your faith in an entity that doesn't share your concerns, and is only aligned with them on accident, for the moment.