Until you genetically engineer all humans to waste calories, crops start failing due to climate change and soil depletion, and humanity dies because of this.
Efficiency might not be good now, but looking at the longer timeline, I don't think we should reasonably assume that the abundance will last. Actually with how things are going right now, I would assume abundance to end in my lifetime.
I am saying it's wrong. Efficiency has a very clear definition in science. Any paper abusing this is unscientific and should have never been published.
We have a few words that are very specific in science. We should not muddle our ability to think about problems by using unclear language.
I think the evolution at play here is not there. It's in self-control and being to maintain a healthy diet in the face of abundance. Indeed, those who can't do that and, for instance, become obese lower their survival rates because of the negative consequences. However this does not seem to affect reproduction rates (or does it?), which is key for evolution.
Obese people are much more efficient in how they use the consumed calories and it's only our "obsession" with being slim that makes the scientists involved use such a twisted interpretation.
For almost every creature in almost every possible context, being obese is an objectively good thing. Being obese means being successful in gathering resources, being successful in avoiding unnecessary effort and struggle. Being obese is the mark of a good mate.
It's only with our usage of the game engine exploits of "cooperation" and "tool use" that we've gotten into a situation where our culture (and bodies) is completely unable to cope with the massive amount of energy we have available.
It's a strange place to find itself for any species.
Surface area is proportional to linear measure squared, volume to linear measure cubed. But given constant height, surface area varies with linear measure, and volume to linear measure squared.
So a quadrupling of volume/weight results in a doubling of surface area. Now if maintaining body temperature above room temperature is a significant expenditure of energy, it would be expected that larger people are more energy efficient and thus less 'efficient' at burning calories per unit weight.
But this article uses "efficient" to mean "efficient at burning more calories".
"To measure people's calorie-burning efficiency, Dr. Indelicato took resting metabolic rate (RMR)--the amount of calories a person needs to burn at rest per day in order to maintain their body weight—and divided it by weight. The result is the metabolic factor (MF), which shows how many calories a person burns per pound of their body weight. The higher the MF, the faster the metabolism."
I'm not saying it's wrong - I'm just saying that we live in a strange time when our bodies haven't evolved to cope with excess calories in our diet.