You're definitely going to pay for the risk one way or another.
So if the price goes up too high before it comes crashing down, your broker might force you to liquidate your position, leaving you with max loses, and no profit from the following crash.
Because puts or calls do not rely on margin and you get to choose if you execute them, so they are more resistant to massive spikes in either direction.
Do note that the implied volatility of a contract is priced-in, so if it's expected to be volatile you'll be paying a premium on it. There are also options strategies that play on just the volatility alone and not the direction.
tldr - buying puts and calls are immune from being force liquidated if it goes in the wrong direction too far, you may hold them until expiration if you wish. Shorts can be margin-called, leaving you without a position in the event it spikes up before going down.
edit: removed mentions of selling options - I found my explanation of those confusing.
Most people are more familiar with buying puts or selling call options are superficially similar - you make money if the price goes down.
Options give the holder the right to buy/sell a share at a specific price before a specific date. They expire worthless after that date.
Shorts are immediately borrowing shares - not just the right to buy/sell shares. They do not generally expire, although they do have interest.
GP said " if they shorted the market." which is a bit ambiguous, it sounds like they are talking about a literal short, but in this context they likely mean either.
tl;dr - no they're different