Companies strive for the pure distillation of their brand. Over time, the identity of successful brands become simpler and simpler because the simpler it is, the easier and quicker it is to identify from afar. What's better than the Nike swoosh with the Nike text on top? Just the swoosh by itself because people know what the swoosh is without you telling them. Starbucks also recently simplified their logo. They dropped the text and emphasised the siren. I wouldn't be surprised if in the future, the Starbucks logo is nothing but a green circle.
Coca-Cola is a master at this. You don't need the cursive white text to know that a red can is probably Coca-Cola. They effectively own the red can. With the new Diet Coke branding, they're trying to do the same for a silver can.
The experiment is trying to establish something similar for HP. When you redesign something, you have to carry over something from previous designs--otherwise it's not something familiar but completely foreign. The agency that did this redesign decided to focus on the angle of the italicised text hoping that HP can eventually "own" anything that is slanted 13°
I wish they had just referred to it as an italic, because that's what it is. But that wouldn't fly.
This reads to a non-designer like myself as pure BS, written merely to justify the likely exhorbitant cost of their work. All that seems missing is a few "paradigms" and "outside the boxes".
Could an experienced logo designer weigh in a let us "pure techies" know if this kind of stuff passes muster with you? Does a 13* angle really convey that much more than a 14* could?
For what it's worth, the new logo looks terrible. The old one had a classic tech look like IBM's.