News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by magic_hamster on Sunday November 06, 2022 @03:07AM (#33490301)
This reads a bit like an alarmist scare. The only real complaint the author has, despite linking it several times, is that SMS is hackable. This is true to some extent, as SIM cloning isn't a straight forward hack and is largely based on social engineering. Still it doesn't really matter for two reasons.

First, common attackers are opportunistic and they are unlikely to know your phone number. Even if they did, it would take skill and effort to clone your SIM. For this to happen you need to be targeted as an individual and that's a different scenario from random PayPal attacks.

Second, PayPal aren't stupid, and they have to be aware of SIM cloning. They also have data that we don't. Looking at their data and the probability of an attacker carrying out SIM cloning, they must have decided the cost of probable cases is acceptable if and when these attacks take place. Or that it's fairly rare to actually happen.

Besides, this option isn't available to all users, so there might be more going on than we realize.

I understand the author is upset that they can't set a single TFA channel to be used exclusively. But I think the real gripe here is that the author feels loss of control rather than a massive security issue.

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by bbarnett on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:04AM (#33490616)
Second, PayPal aren't stupid

I presume you have loads of verifiable data, to prove this?

Or is this a logical fallacy? EG, appeal to authority?

Corps of all sizes do very, very stupid things.

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by xdfgh1112 on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:30AM (#33490751)
Is there a term for the opposite - presuming you're smarter than a huge team of full time employees with specialist knowledge and access to data you don't have?
Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by bbarnett on Sunday November 06, 2022 @05:13AM (#33491036)
The way you are thinking, is a logical fallacy. Right or wrong, is not determined by the source.
Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by wizzwizz4 on Sunday November 06, 2022 @07:10AM (#33491755)
Argument screens off authority, but you do actually have to have a better argument than the authority figure. Saying "I have an argument, and the experts aren't on Hacker News so we don't know what theirs is" doesn't make it a logical fallacy to disagree with you.

And just because an argument's a logical fallacy, that doesn't make it incorrect. https://existentialcomics.com/comic/9

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by pbhjpbhj on Sunday November 06, 2022 @08:26AM (#33492365)
>just because an argument's a logical fallacy, that doesn't make it incorrect. //

An argument that uses fallacious reasoning is an incorrect argument, but pointing out a fallacy doesn't negate a conclusion (that would be the fallacy fallacy).

So, we can't tell if the conclusion is wrong when someone uses a fallacy.

I'm guessing your link laid it out clearly.

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by wizzwizz4 on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:16PM (#33497273)
My link did – but I'm making a stronger claim. (A tangential claim, mind.) Just because an argument pattern-matches to a named logical fallacy, that doesn't make it incorrect.

Take the conjunction fallacy. Ultimately, it comes down to the representativeness heuristic. However, the representativeness heuristic matches how we use language: to use Wikipedia's example, "Linda is a bank teller active in the feminist movement" is more correct than "Linda is a bank teller" if Linda is active in the feminist movement, but not a bank teller.

The mistake in such a situation is interpreting it as though the speaker is using classical logic, when they're actually using a fuzzy logic more akin to Bayesian inference. People focus too much on logical fallacies, and not enough on how the average human actually uses language. Precise language is useful, but that doesn't make "heuristic language" wrong, or fallacious.

An argument that's a logical fallacy can still be heuristically correct.

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by xdfgh1112 on Monday November 07, 2022 @02:05PM (#33510628)
Yes if we're talking about pure logic, but we aren't.
Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by pbhjpbhj on Sunday November 06, 2022 @08:40AM (#33492515)
In their defence, sometimes organisations are stupid where individuals are not.

Many people might realise that cloning is an unaccounted for aspect of a 2FA, but the manager in charge, say, thinks cloning is not a realistic possibility and so doesn't allow it to be taken into account. Or, the manager does think it needs addressing but they get a bonus if the system is completed earlier and they know it will take longer to address the issue, so they argue it's not a realistic attack ...

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by superjan on Sunday November 06, 2022 @05:33AM (#33491146)
> most new iPhones and Android phones by default will display the actual contents of your messages on the lock screen

So stealing a phone and knowing an email address could be enough. New iphones require face id by default, but there loads of cheaper android models that don’t. That is a low bar.

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by heisenbit on Sunday November 06, 2022 @07:19AM (#33491805)
Depending on your phone settings the message content will be displayed on your lock screen without the need to go through face id.

Apple and Google should agree on a standard code sms format and prevent such sensitive information getting displayed on the lock screen.

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by dzhiurgis on Sunday November 06, 2022 @07:27AM (#33491847)
Apple should default not displaying anything on lock screen. There’s a setting that most don’t know about.
Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by sgerenser on Sunday November 06, 2022 @08:41AM (#33492521)
Ever since the first FaceId iPhone (iPhone X) the default for messages is to only show message previews when unlocked. I’m pretty sure non FaceID phones defaulted to not showing previews at all.
Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by yencabulator on Sunday November 06, 2022 @10:08AM (#33493381)
> Apple and Google should agree on a standard code sms format and prevent such sensitive information getting displayed on the lock screen.

W3C tried: https://github.com/wicg/sms-one-time-codes

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by edualm on Sunday November 06, 2022 @10:29AM (#33493626)
So that’s what it is!

SMS 2FA from Apple actually implements that standard from what I can see.

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by fancyfredbot on Sunday November 06, 2022 @05:41AM (#33491197)
So basically, since you need to be targeted as an individual rather than at random, and that's rare, then we should be okay with an insecure /banking/ website? I can't get my head around that point of view. This is certainly a very real security issue, particularly for anyone with a public profile and widely known contact details.
Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by rippercushions on Sunday November 06, 2022 @06:55AM (#33491639)
> PayPal aren't stupid

As discussed very recently, many HNers would contest that assertion.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item ?id=33463535

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by jurschreuder on Sunday November 06, 2022 @07:34AM (#33491897)
PayPal probably has data that it will get more users if it's convenient to log in and some people get hacked.

I don't know if every user of PayPal would agree with this strategy, even though it makes PayPal the most money.

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by slv77 on Sunday November 06, 2022 @08:32AM (#33492428)
People lose their second factors which are intentionally difficult to clone. Phones get replaced, keys get lost. OTP is a more secure fallback method then calling customer support.

I can’t think of another universally available fallback method.

Re:PayPal Allows Bypassing Two-Factor Authentication with a ... by hakfoo on Monday November 07, 2022 @09:19PM (#33515211)
s/PayPal/the entire bloody financial industry/g

They've decided it's pretty much always better to close the barn doors after the cows leave.

Card fraud problems? Just promise people 'zero liability' rather than some sort of security paradigm stronger than "we told everyone they're not allowed to store the CVV."

Everything identity-theft related? Why bother actually engineering some sort of secure 21st-century authentication systems when you can just pay for a few months of credit monitoring after the inevitable data breach and class action suit.

I wonder if it would be possible to create a more proactive liability framework. Maybe stockholders would be a party with standing-- if you're still doing $known_stupid_thing years after alternatives have been documented, you're failing your fiduciary duty to investors, just waiting for an avoidable damage to the stock price to happen.