News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quantum Winter Is Coming by kragen on Saturday November 05, 2022 @04:26PM (#33485297)
Analog computers have mostly been electronic rather than mechanical for 60 years. "Digital" and "electronic" are not synonyms; they are completely orthogonal. Analog computers 60 years ago were mostly built with op-amps rather than shafts and gears, despite the survival of WWII-era mechanical naval fire control computers. That's in large part because human-scale shafts and gears max out with signals in the hertz to kilohertz range, while even the most ordinary op-amps can handle signals in the tens of kilohertz range (which has been true for 100 years) and op-amps in the tens of megahertz range have been available for 60 years. Also, shafts and gears have inherent errors of around 1% from backlash, while op-amps can usually do better than 0.1% (again, for the last 100 years) and by 60 years ago better than 0.001%.

So with off-the-shelf electronics an analog computer can compute 1000 times faster with 1000 times better precision than if it were mechanical. Until the 01960s they used vacuum tubes and so used more power and were less reliable; since then electronics have used less power and been more reliable.

Today we still use plenty of analog computation, but it's pushed to the margins. Every sound card has an antialiasing analog filter on its front end before switching to the digital domain. Even software-defined radios still use analog electronics to upconvert and downconvert signals between baseband or IF and the RF. Your Wi-Fi card can't sample that 2.4 GHz signal at its 4.8 Gsps Nyquist rate; doing that is not impossible but still requires high-end digital electronics. Submillimeter-wave communication is very much dependent on precise analog signal processing to modulate your desired signal into the hundreds of GHz range.

("Precise" in this case doesn't mean with linearity errors as low as 1%.)

There are no comments on this comment yet.