I also happen to work on a project with 24k+ files, which even with an SSD TextMate does not do well with. I have a script to generate a tmproj file[1] that contains the files I want to make it manageable.
New windows should be a part of the same project they were opened from.
I use and love the 3rd party tool SizeUp, but SublimeText2's integrated pane management (including moving tabs between them) is far better than plain windows.
Want to view two files? Ctrl-right on one, it's now on the right side of the screen.
Command-O, chose the new file, Ctrl-left on it, it's now on the left side.
I'm honestly very curious what Sublime/etc offer that is better than what you can do with the OS?
Because there are so many benefits of having multiple buffers/files open within the same Vim instance it makes sense to have multiple buffers viewable at once, not to have only one viewable at a time. You lose a lot of editing power if buffers are not open in same Vim instance; it doesn't make sense to open a new file separately in different Vim instance. Moreover, many times split windows are useful to show two different views of the _same_ buffer at once.
Granted, I only know that from using VIM (and occasionally SublimeText), but it's been one of my "Dear GOD Give Me This in TM" requests for a while. I've got SizeUp and love it - truly one of my must-have apps - but to me it's a hack, not a solution.
Do other windows start inheriting the project drawer if older windows are closed?
Each window has multiple tabs - how do you tear off and replant them using the keyboard?
Doh, now the temporary horizontal split panes like find-in-project, the python console, etc, must be attached to a specific narrow window.
And so on. I like a multi window desktop and am certainly not a maximise-everything guy. But relying on the OS for everything is not optimal.
(or whatever your editor of choice calls its synchronized side-by-side diff mode)
When I want to view two files at the same time, I open two windows, and put them side by side.
Not everything needs to be fullscreen all-the-time. Let the OS manage windows. It's better at it!
Besides, having windows automatically become half-maximized is easy with the right tools, like BetterTouchTool (Do it with a gesture!), or Divvy.