News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by jacknews on Saturday November 05, 2022 @09:20AM (#33481191)
Isn't this a deliberate model, and not only for pharma?

Govt funds the risky research, and then hands the baton to competitive industry, which is good at 'finding markets', making it a product, and optimizing costs.

Eg, google, amazon, etc, would not exist without the govt early (and continuing) funding of the tech their business is based on.

What is then supposed to happen is that profits are taxed sufficiently, feeding back in to the system, but that part appears to have broken down lately.

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by efficax on Saturday November 05, 2022 @10:01AM (#33481555)
yes, it’s deliberate. it’s a deliberate way of using taxpayer dollars to enrich private citizens without providing taxpayer benefits.
Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by Arnt on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:56PM (#33483868)
If that's right, shouldn't there be a flood of new companies looking to get the dollars? Is there such a flood, or at least a stream? I haven't noticed one, but I don't really try…
Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by pessimizer on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:12PM (#33484053)
It's not a program to support small businesses, it's a structure to support massive companies who lobby and hire politicians and their friends and family.
Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by Arnt on Sunday November 06, 2022 @10:11AM (#33493426)
In that case, shouldn't there be a flood, or at least a stream, of existing big companies setting up new subsidiaries to take advantage of this? There are many big companies with existing lobbyist divisions, deep pockets and experience in broadly similar areas. Food, cosmetics, chemicals spring to mind.
Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by colinsane on Saturday November 05, 2022 @10:06AM (#33481596)
> What is then supposed to happen is that profits are taxed sufficiently, feeding back in to the system, but that part appears to have broken down lately.

right. with the right accounting processes, i could buy the rest. but when spending and tax collection are as decoupled or loosely balanced as they appear to be today, public investment into private industry is super risky.

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by Throwawayaerlei on Saturday November 05, 2022 @10:36AM (#33481867)
Only read the beginning of this screed, but its a unique and unlikely to be repeated situation until the next pandemic model. "Competitive industry" normally spends the big bucks to do Phase II and especially expensive Phase III trials. And as you note, manufacturing it. Which Pfizer did without Operation Warp Speed money until it started failing to deliver on its promises in December 2020. May have gotten some money from Germany through BioNTech which was the company that actually developed it.

The claim "By one estimate, the National Institutes of Health spent $17 billion on vaccine technologies fundamental to the Covid-19 vaccine." goes back to the mid-20th Century, is so broad as to be useless and is obviously disqualifying propaganda: https://medicalxpress.com/news/2021-04-covid-vaccine-built-b...

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by cdtwigg on Saturday November 05, 2022 @12:53PM (#33483200)
Yeah it’s the trials that are really expensive, not the basic research. The government gets to spread its dollars around to lots of individual researchers but if they were instead using that money to fund phase III trials (1) we’d have a lot a lot less money for basic research (2) we’d fund a lot fewer phase III trials so (3) we’d see much less drug development overall. Also I’d worry about a potential conflict of interest if the same government is conducting and evaluating the results of drug trials.
Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by s1artibartfast on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:29PM (#33484221)
Never mind the fact that 17 billion is less than the annual R&D spend at one Pharma company.

I think I'm more interesting comparison would be all national funding for drug R&D versus all corporate R&D funding. This could be done on an annual basis or historic

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by rayiner on Saturday November 05, 2022 @12:39PM (#33483067)
Economists broadly agree that taxing corporate profits is inefficient. From an NPR show surveying five economists across the political spectrum about what are consensus ideas in the field: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/07/19/157047211/six-... (“Eliminate the corporate income tax. Completely. If companies reinvest the money into their businesses, that's good. Don't tax companies in an effort to tax rich people.”).

The problem in the US isn’t that we don’t tax Google, Amazon, etc. Look at the corporate taxes in France or Sweden. They’re about the same. The problem is that we don’t sufficiently tax the billions in payroll at those companies.

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by sneak on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:54PM (#33483848)
> The problem is that we don’t sufficiently tax the billions in payroll at those companies.

The government isn’t short on money.

Are we sure that the problem isn’t that we are spending Elon Musk’s entire lifetime net worth on the military each and every 90 days while not even at war? We shovel twenty tons of hundred dollar bills (about $2bn) into the neverending pit of the war machine every day.

I’m not convinced more government revenue is the solution to any problems, given what they are doing with their current insanely large levels of revenue at present.

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by rayiner on Saturday November 05, 2022 @03:05PM (#33484570)
> The government isn’t short on money.

It surely is. The federal government ran a $880 billion deficit in 2018.

> Are we sure that the problem isn’t that we are spending Elon Musk’s entire lifetime net worth on the military each and every 90 days while not even at war?

Yes, definitely. Total government spending at all levels (federal + state + local) is about $7 trillion. The military budget is only 1/10 of that. If we cut our defense spending to the NATO 2% of GDP target, we would save only about $300 billion. We need to cut twice that just to close the structural deficit, and raise taxes by about another trillion to pay for universal healthcare.

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by candiodari on Saturday November 05, 2022 @03:49PM (#33484924)
> It surely is. The federal government ran a $880 billion deficit in 2018.

You do realise the government is supposed to run a deficit, right? That's quite literally where money comes from.

You can make the case that it's too big ... and it is, but it should run a deficit.

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by rayiner on Saturday November 05, 2022 @04:04PM (#33485082)
That’s not how it works at all.
Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by feet on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:26PM (#33487033)
Care to expand on that?
Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by rayiner on Saturday November 05, 2022 @08:42PM (#33487511)
The M0 money supply increased from $350 billion to $900 billion from 1990 to 2008. During that time the federal debt increased from $3 trillion to $9 trillion. So the debt (due to the structural budget deficit) increased vastly faster than the portion of the money supply attributable to printing currency.

Moreover, most money is not created by the government printing money, it's created by federal reserve purchases of debt or bank lending. Neither of those are reflected in the deficit. The prior poster is thus incorrect to say that the government "needs" to run a budget deficit "because that's where money comes form."

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by JamesBarney on Saturday November 05, 2022 @08:46PM (#33487539)
Given inflation and GDP growth you would want some deficit spending in order to keep a constant debt to GDP ratio.
Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by hakfoo on Sunday November 06, 2022 @01:04AM (#33489199)
But will that be effective too?

I guess I look at the CEOs who take a symbolic $1 salary-- they're reliant on either selling their plumped securities and other assets (at a low capital-gains tax rate) or borrowing against them (at zero tax rate) to actually cash out living expenses.

The right answer is to just nationalize profitable industries and use them as direct revenue streams. This eliminates much of the need for a formal tax-assessment (return processing, auditing, etc.) system, creating an immediate user-experience improvement and streamlining, and cuts out a lot of the opportunities to cheat. It's not like you can use creative accounting to boost your gas mileage (and reduce your spend at a state-run oil company). Not to mention the huge opportunities to manage for social/political aims (i. e. a state-run telecom will probably honour build-out commitments better than Verizon, because their jobs are all directly accountable to angry legislators)

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by jacknews on Sunday November 06, 2022 @09:49AM (#33493175)
The problem is not payroll, but shareholder dividends, capital gains and share buy-backs, and the corporate debt to pay for all of these.
Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by rayiner on Sunday November 06, 2022 @11:05AM (#33494017)
Dividends and capital gains are taxed. Why would corporate debt be taxed?

Yes the problem is the payroll. Silicon Valley people engineers making $500k/year are the most under-taxed people in the country compared to European nations. Our corporate or capital gains taxes are unexceptional. It’s our taxes on the upper middle class—which haven’t been raised since Reagan-that are unusual. These people are the backbone of the tax base funding the welfare state in other countries.

Re:The Public Shouldn’t Pay for Drugs Twice by s1artibartfast on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:21PM (#33484143)
>What is then supposed to happen is that profits are taxed sufficiently, feeding back in to the system, but that part appears to have broken down lately.

How do you figure? Tax revenues are basically at all time high, and going up further.

Consider that 40% of US GDP now is collected in some form of taxation.[1] 40 cents of every dollar earned is taxed and spent as the government chooses. This is more than between FDR and Regan, and much more than the 20s (~15% of GDP)

Also consider that size of the pie has also increased! US real GDP per capita (accounting for inflation) has grown ~4x since the 1940s, and total GDP has grown ~20x! [2]

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/37/Federal%...

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/A939RX0Q048SBEA