Re:Canada to introduce 2% tax on stock buybacks starting in ...
by andrewmcwatters on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:09PM
(#33469036)
On the matter of security repurchase legality: I don't understand how you can have meaningful equity ownership without equity repurchases.
Imagine you buy an apartment with two partners to produce some cashflow. One partner wants out and to use his or her capital for another interest. The two other partners would need to buy him or her out OR resell the share of interest to another partner.
Imagine it being illegal for you to buy back your equity with your remaining partner.
It makes no sense.
Now take it a step further. Let's say you can split your equity without bound, but can never reconsolidate it. How absurd would that be? Now you're forced to have an amount of equity partners proportional to your total shares and can never decrease the number of holders?
Taxation of purchasable equity is another matter entirely.
Imagine you buy an apartment with two partners to produce some cashflow. One partner wants out and to use his or her capital for another interest. The two other partners would need to buy him or her out OR resell the share of interest to another partner.
Imagine it being illegal for you to buy back your equity with your remaining partner.
It makes no sense.
Now take it a step further. Let's say you can split your equity without bound, but can never reconsolidate it. How absurd would that be? Now you're forced to have an amount of equity partners proportional to your total shares and can never decrease the number of holders?
Taxation of purchasable equity is another matter entirely.