Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot
by adriand on Thursday November 03, 2022 @06:32PM
(#33458833)
If I use Photoshop to create an image that is identical to a registered trademark, is the rights violation my fault or Adobe’s fault?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot
by kyruzic on Thursday November 03, 2022 @06:37PM
(#33458901)
No because that's not a trademark violation in anyway. Using GPL code in a non GPL project is a violation of copyright law though.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot
by xigoi on Thursday November 03, 2022 @06:36PM
(#33458877)
Photoshop can't produce copyrighted images on its own.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot
by metadat on Thursday November 03, 2022 @06:40PM
(#33458935)
To play devil's advocate: Co-Pilot can't reproduce copyrighted without the appropriate user input.
I don't really hold this opinion, just making a point- this analogy is flawed.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot
by heavyset_go on Thursday November 03, 2022 @06:52PM
(#33459075)
If I draw some eyes in Photoshop, it won't automatically draw the Mona Lisa around it for me.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot
by WithinReason on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:27PM
(#33459404)
If you Google Mona Lisa the result is the Mona Lisa. If you query Copilot for a common piece of code you get that code.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot
by heavyset_go on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:15PM
(#33459909)
Google doesn't sell its search feature as a product that you can just plagiarize the results from and they're yours. Microsoft does that with Copilot.
Copilot is as much of a search engine as Stable Diffusion or DALL-e are, which is to say they aren't at all. If you want to compare it to a search engine, despite it being a tortured metaphor, the most apt comparison is not to Google, but to The Pirate Bay if TPB stored all of their copyrighted content and served it up themselves.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot
by WithinReason on Friday November 04, 2022 @04:09AM
(#33463407)
With Copilot it's your responsibility not to use it as a search engine to copy-paste code. It's completely obvious when it's being used as a search engine so it's not a problem at all.
Stable Diffusion works on completely different principles and they can't exactly replicate a pixels from their training data.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot
by metadat on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:00PM
(#33459154)
Until you sprinkle a bit of Stable Diffusion V2 or 3 on it, or perhaps some GaN.
The more I think about it, the more this all seems like another dimension of Jack and the Magic Beanstalk crossed with The Matrix.