News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RawTherapee by busyant on Thursday November 03, 2022 @12:13PM (#33453265)
> Darktable tames noise at around ISO 3200, a lot of resolution and color is lost.

Could you elaborate on what this means?

I tried Darktable a few months ago, and no matter how hard I tried, my images just looked "washed out".

I assume this is what you mean. I really wanted to use DT because the parametric masking features were pretty nice, but every image looked vaguely bleached.

Re:RawTherapee by bobsomers on Thursday November 03, 2022 @12:26PM (#33453466)
If you've got 50 minutes for a very complete and in depth answer, this video by Aurelien who works on the pixel pipe covers why Darktable tends to look washed out (out of the box) compared to other apps and how to conceptualize what it's doing and why: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZCwB7FogUs
Re:RawTherapee by busyant on Thursday November 03, 2022 @12:32PM (#33453552)
Thank you. That's actually one of the videos that I watched a few months back. It helped a little bit, but not enough for my tastes.

It just seemed like there was a LOT of extra tweaking I needed to do for each image. My suspicion is that if you want to use DT (effectively), you need to have a deep understanding of color theory and image processing (at least more than I am willing to devote).

I also enjoyed his rant(s) on the new releases of DT, especially the complaints about the UI.

Re:RawTherapee by nuclx on Thursday November 03, 2022 @01:32PM (#33454480)
I had similar experiences with DT. When taking RAW+JPG I always struggled to create an edit of the RAW in DT that is more satisfying than the out of camera JPG - and I watched quite a few videos and read a few guides, also trying to work with scene-referred workflow introduced in DT4. I'm currently giving Capture One a shot (Express version is free for Sony users) and I'm really pleased how accessible the UI is. Applying default adjustments already gives a great starting point for further tweaking (similar or better than the OOC JPG). Recovering highlights also works way better than in DT. It just felt like the algorithms in DT are sometimes not quite on the same level.

I never tried RawTherapee.

Re:RawTherapee by busyant on Thursday November 03, 2022 @02:57PM (#33455703)
> I'm currently giving Capture One a shot

This is what I use, too.

I did a lot of side-by-side comparisons between C1 & DT on my raw files and I could not get DT to make anything that looked like C1's automatic adjustments.

The best I could determine is that the out-of-the-box adjustments made by C1 were somewhat complex (e.g., it wasn't a 'simple' transformation of rgb values).

Obviously, it's preferable to know what's happening under the hood instead of relying on black-magic, but I just didn't have the time to invest in trying to figure that out.

C1 is really nice. I also compared it to Lightroom and I didn't like those results as much as C1.

edit: Although C1's masking features are excellent, I wish they had more parametric masking features. That's the one thing I miss from DT.