News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Snap Store administrators removed signal-desktop from Ubu... by freedomben on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:29AM (#33452537)
Is the third party maintainer relationship a policy choice by flatpak? or is that just the case because the maintainer built the flatpak first?
Re:Snap Store administrators removed signal-desktop from Ubu... by smallerfish on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:31AM (#33452568)
It's because Zoom / Jetbrains haven't stepped up to package their software as flatpak, so volunteers got in there. There's a flathub policy that a flatpak project will be handed over to the vendor to maintain if they make that request - which is definitely good, but the fact of those volunteers being able to do this (however well intentioned) is not.
Re:Snap Store administrators removed signal-desktop from Ubu... by smoldesu on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:37AM (#33452681)
Yep. On top of that, some people just straight-up don't intend to port their software to Flatpak. There are a lot of unofficially supported packages (or incomplete ports) that will remain that way forever, which really makes Flatpak no better than the AUR in many respects.

The biggest problem IMO is that Flatpak coupled itself too closely with Bubblewrap. Flatpak is missing many key features because of this (support for running services???), and it makes zero sense in the context of a modern desktop. Apps like Flatseal should focus on sandboxing regular applications with Bubblewrap rather than trying to manage all of the software on it's own. As-is, Flatpak is the last resort of packaging methods for all of my systems, even behind Snap.

Re:Snap Store administrators removed signal-desktop from Ubu... by SSLy on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:39AM (#33452699)
This is no worse than distro contributors or say, AUR or Nixpkgs folks packaging 3rd non-free party software.
Re:Snap Store administrators removed signal-desktop from Ubu... by krageon on Thursday November 03, 2022 @12:09PM (#33453194)
Being able to autonomously do things as a community is healthy. All this corporate pandering is not.
Re:Snap Store administrators removed signal-desktop from Ubu... by asveikau on Thursday November 03, 2022 @12:15PM (#33453296)
Zoom isn't required to "step up" and use your favorite packager or distribution mechanism.
Re:Snap Store administrators removed signal-desktop from Ubu... by Spivak on Thursday November 03, 2022 @03:30PM (#33456182)
Flatpak is more like Docker than Snap. Flathub, an unaffiliated 3rd party that uses the Flatpak format and provides a Flatpak repo -- Flathub, allows people to publish packages to their repo that aren't the official developers.