From the freedom/privacy standpoint, however, I'm not sure. I find it surprisingly easy to imagine a US government agency empowered by anti-terror laws to get access to my data.
This is why I want encrypted cloud computing for all my stuff. I dunno if the large players could actually do that and have the US govt be ok with it.
But then there's also the fact that i have access to a decent set of hdd's and can store it locally rather with ease.with the cost being the attention and time of running smartctl once in a while to check the health of the hdd's and getting a backup...
Verifying that data going across the wire is encrypted is fairly easy to do.
You check the data going out is encrypted and that it is encrypted when it comes back. Is that enough verification for you?
Depending on how much you trust the vendor you can go further - run it in a debugger and check where it gets the key for example.
You lock down access to files like private keys as much as possible to minimize the possibility of this.
For example (not affiliated): https://yubico.com/
Basically when I installed it, it had to be compiled by you and installed on an SD card. You could easily change a setting on the system and drop to a shell. It was running on a stripped-down Ubuntu installation, so you could actually install Firefox inside of ChromeOS. It was nice having the base, fast-boot installation combined with the ability to basically run a full system if you needed to.
just like xterm != bash
The potential appeal of the Chrome notebook is its security-by-simplicity. If the only thing you can do is use Chromium, then your notebook is basically as secure as Chromium itself is (in theory, at least).
The irony is that we're essentially moving back to the way computers were a few decades ago - people used terminals to access a central computer. We moved to personal desktop computers for a while, then laptops (and mobile phones). It'll be interesting to see if the rise of interest in 'cloud computing' means that, in five years, our primary computers will just be portable terminals to access some main computer remotely.
Personally, I might be fine with that. Network speeds/reliability aside, everything I do could be accomplished easily over SSH, with X forwarding for a few applications. It's possible that these simple tools that we've had for decades could be packaged in a way that appeals to a more general use case.