News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As Last Module Docks, China Completes Its Space Station by ElevenLathe on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @04:42PM (#33427209)
It's true in a way but just pushes things back a level of causality: if we train more people as aerospace engineers, then we will have fewer trained people in other specialties. We have a finite supply of enthusiastic, smart young people to drive change. The best answer of course is "do both" and make sure more of our young people are happy, enthusiastic, and able to access necessary training and education.

There are also skills that overlap: every welder that SpaceX or Lockheed employs is one less welder able to help install a water treatment plant somewhere. Here again, the solution is to train more welders.

Re:As Last Module Docks, China Completes Its Space Station by ch4s3 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @06:12PM (#33428331)
> if we train

People choose those paths on their own, not because some human industrial policy plucked them out of middle school and put them on that path.

Re:As Last Module Docks, China Completes Its Space Station by ElevenLathe on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @08:12PM (#33429740)
Nonetheless, if they choose to be an aerospace engineer, they've chosen not to be, for example, a surgeon, or whatever else.
Re:As Last Module Docks, China Completes Its Space Station by ch4s3 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:16PM (#33430244)
Yes, that is how choice and specialization work, we don't live in a feudal or autocratic system where heredity or fiat determine your life path.
Re:As Last Module Docks, China Completes Its Space Station by ElevenLathe on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @09:06AM (#33435062)
I didn't say any of that?
Re:As Last Module Docks, China Completes Its Space Station by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @08:37PM (#33429945)
> We have a finite supply of enthusiastic, smart young people to drive change

And currently most of them go into trading, which is a zero-sum game, or into building another social network that causes depression.

Look at top-ten list of high paying jobs, and ask youself how much crucial work for society they do

Re:As Last Module Docks, China Completes Its Space Station by lambdadmitry on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @08:46AM (#33434827)
Trading is not exactly zero sum. Trading is price discovery + arbitrage, both of which are useful even if imperfect.
Re:As Last Module Docks, China Completes Its Space Station by XorNot on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @08:57PM (#33430080)
You don't have a finite supply of people. Because people get to choose what they do. Even the dictatorships can't order people to become a good X if they don't have the interest.

It's the height of entitlement to think you're able to demand more of some profession come into existence. The worst regimes on earth can't manage it. The most you get to do is incentivize and make available the training and access and process to maybe get more of that. That's it.

Re:As Last Module Docks, China Completes Its Space Station by ElevenLathe on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @11:48AM (#33437746)
We absolutely can do it, and have. Post-sputnik, government funding poured into STEM, and we convinced huge amounts of young people that they wanted to be scientists and engineers, and nobody was coerced into anything. We trained enough engineers in that short time to staff a literal moonshot program plus every half-baked weapons system idea that crossed a desk anywhere in the Pentagon plus tons of other more speculative stuff like packet switching networks (aka ethernet, the internet, etc.).

It's not necessary to dictate any individual person's career in order to shift the numbers in aggregate.