News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

HN via RSS is annoying, this is how it should work

I, like many folk here I'm guessing, read HN via RSS.

And, when I wanna click through on a story have this annoying experience whereby.

a. I click through 'comments' and then have to click to the main story and then back to read the comments (sucky)

b. I click on the main story element (all too often) and miss out on the comments here

I'm not suggesting iframes, or anything ;) Oh heck, I might be... but fundamentally I'd like to have one click which gets me to the story and then follows on with the HN comments.

Any chance?

( 4 comments | 6 points | on HN )
Re:HN via RSS is annoying, this is how it should work by ggchappell on Monday December 12, 2011 @11:24PM (#3346279)
Your problem has nothing to do with RSS. I have it, too, reading HN in the "normal" manner. My solution is, when I go to a story, to open two tabs: one with the story and one with the HN comments. Then I can switch between them.

Still, I would welcome a more automatic solution, but I don't know what it would look like. (The comment by bmelton on the Digg bar is quite correct.)

Re:HN via RSS is annoying, this is how it should work by jaredsohn on Sunday December 11, 2011 @10:05PM (#3342063)
I don't think this is an RSS-specific issue. If you read Hacker News from the main page, you would experience the same workflow.
Re:HN via RSS is annoying, this is how it should work by farms on Sunday December 11, 2011 @10:54PM (#3342168)
Doesn't make it any less annoying ;)

It'd be nice to have a page + comments somehow.

Re:HN via RSS is annoying, this is how it should work by bmelton on Monday December 12, 2011 @12:01AM (#3342352)
You're looking for something like the Digg bar, basically. There are other implementations of the same sort of thing, but by and large, people tend to hate them.