Re:Attempting Linux on Microsoft Dev Kit 2023
by realgeniushere on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @07:32AM
(#33419782)
Unrealistic and unfair expectations here. Microsoft isn’t doing anything to stop you from booting other OSes on this device. OpenBSD devs did the work, so OpenBSD boots on it. Linux devs now need to do the same if they want to support this dev kit. Not Microsoft’s problem.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Attempting Linux on Microsoft Dev Kit 2023
by tyingq on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @07:40AM
(#33419855)
>OpenBSD devs did the work
It doesn't appear they did anything specific for this kit, nothing obvious in the changelog anyway. Perhaps just some combination of things they've done for other UEFI bootable Arm64 hardware.
Re:Attempting Linux on Microsoft Dev Kit 2023
by realgeniushere on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @07:51AM
(#33419955)
Okay. Anyway, OpenBSD works, proving that there’s nothing stopping Linux from working except the time and interest of Linux developers. I’m sure they are interested and the necessary modifications will be made soon enough.
Re:Attempting Linux on Microsoft Dev Kit 2023
by contextfree on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @07:40AM
(#33419864)
The article seems like less a critique and more of an informational report of this person's experience.
Re:Attempting Linux on Microsoft Dev Kit 2023
by realgeniushere on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @07:42AM
(#33419879)
>Whilst I enjoy this kind of tinkering, it was disappointing that a "Dev Kit", built for developers can neither boot Linux, nor enable a custom Linux Kernel for WSL2.
What's that I hear Hacker News and Reddit cry? "It's a Dev Kit for Windows, you moron!" That may be the case, but Microsoft "Loves Linux", and clearly has worked hard to make WSL2 available out of the box on these devices.
It’s not a scathing attack or anything, but it is in fact critical of Microsoft.
Re:Attempting Linux on Microsoft Dev Kit 2023
by contextfree on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:34AM
(#33421007)
Fair enough, but those were a couple sentences out of a multipage article. I just get tired of comments for any article that involves Microsoft in some way turning into generic arguments over whether people should like or hate Microsoft, overshadowing the actual content of the article. The arguments tend to rehash the same tropes over and over and are pretty tedious and not interesting.
But I guess I'm just adding to the problem by turning it into an equally tedious meta-argument. I'll stop now ...
Re:Attempting Linux on Microsoft Dev Kit 2023
by rzzzt on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @07:49AM
(#33419938)
Embedded-looking systems usually need an FDT blob for booting Linux, this seems to be the missing piece according to the article. It shouldn't be hard to provide it on the hardware developer's end, while a bit more complicated to infer from the OS developer side.
Re:Attempting Linux on Microsoft Dev Kit 2023
by realgeniushere on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @07:27AM
(#33434069)
And yet, somehow, OpenBSD works just fine already. Perhaps relatedly, this device is UEFI based, so unlike most ARM devices, it has a standard boot process and hardware enumeration mechanism.