News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by seydor on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @04:51AM (#33418567)
Can be rephrased as, all cars will require a heavy, difficult-to-produce, difficult-to-recycle battery that needs a huge reliable supply chain to make it happen, and cities that can withstand the load of charging hundreds of thousands of cars in the evening. Europe doesn't even have the money to do those things so i will dismiss this as the same kind of populism that brought germany to the brink of recession.
Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by uniqueuid on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @04:59AM (#33418628)
I don't think you should call this populism. After all, many consumers will be critical of the measure. In fact it's the opposite - a progressive policy.

And of course all the points you are listing as weaknesses completely ignore the existing negative externalities (such as health impacts from emissions, tire wear and noise, economic dependence, and of course the long-term impact on the environment). So even if your pessimistic takes are correct, we need to compare them to the alternatives to get a sober judgement.

Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by nikbackm on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @05:08AM (#33418699)
Tire wear and noise will not get better with electric cars, more likely worse due to their greater weight.
Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by thecopy on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @05:18AM (#33418773)
Fully agree. We need to shift away from car-dependency in dense urban centres. Why should everyone be able to drive their space-taking, noisy, toxic, air-conditioned box which is dangerous to everyone else into all strees in an urban centre? That the majority see no issue with this is society wide "Mere-exposure effect" bias in effect.
Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by seydor on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @08:38AM (#33420330)
You can reduce car use, instead of asking people to buy another car
Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by marcyb5st on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @05:16AM (#33418760)
I think 92% of the batteries components can be recycled at the moment, and WV set a target to get to 97% [1]. Moreover lithium is expensive to extract and a rare resource. So I am confident that in this case recycling at scale will happen.

My major gripe is that a lot of people will be without a job once we fully transition to EV. They have few moving parts and so production lines requires way fewer people. The same goes for maintenance in the long run. In countries like Germany where a huge percent of the population works in the automotive industry directly or indirectly it will be a big deal IMHO. But as always with politicians they won't act until the problems hit their potential voters.

[1] https://www.edfenergy.com/electric-cars/batteries

Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by raydiatian on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @04:54AM (#33418589)
So, fatalistically accept that climate change is happening and we don’t have a choice?

Or stop driving cars altogether? (I like this plan most)

Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by flockonus on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @05:01AM (#33418640)
imho, too little too late. At this point we need carbon negative solutions, not only incremental improvements (combustion car -> electric car), this is the same lack of ambition as banning plastic bags on grocery stores in 2022, might have been a timeline solution in 2000.
Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by thdespou on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @04:55AM (#33418602)
Stop PCP payments first and then we will see how many can afford a car.
Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by DocTomoe on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @05:01AM (#33418646)
So, what is your living situation? Inner city? If so: Do you expect everyone to move in with you? How do you get your food (and - you'll likely buy it from somewhere - how does it get there)?

Stopping individual traffic is a pipe dream. Climate change is happening, and we don't have a choice, nor will we be able to stop it - so we do what has always been the major advantage of our species: quick and rapid adaption. Accept that some land is lost, and move to places that are more habitable. Install air conditioning / heating where necessary. Change agriculture to focus on new produce that is more adapted to the climatical circumstances. And start working on a Plan(et) B, because we have only a few more hundred years.

Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by raydiatian on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @05:05AM (#33418670)
> few more hundred years

Wow that seems like a generous figure. I’d guess fifty at best.

Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by DocTomoe on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:29AM (#33433194)
As a child of the Cold War, when human extinction was hours, not years away, I may have become a bit more conservative with doomsday forecasts.
Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by djbebs on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @04:55AM (#33418603)
Climate change isn't nearly as big of an issue as the proposed solutions
Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by throw_a_grenade on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @05:08AM (#33418700)
And would require that no war would happen, where attacker deliberately targets civilian electrical infrastructure, like Russia right now in Ukraine. Like it or not, ICE-powered cars save lives, because you can pack your family and escape those rapists and murderers.
Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by sofixa on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @05:15AM (#33418755)
> Like it or not, ICE-powered cars save lives, because you can pack your family and escape those rapists and murderers.

Unless you're out of fuel because the invader destroyed the infrastructure and has control over supplies?

Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by throw_a_grenade on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @05:48AM (#33418974)
There's an order of magnitude difference in ease of handling energy. You can carry the fuel in cans, hold it in pallet containers in a shed. You can pump fuel between cars using just a pipe and gravity, for example from broken or abandoned vevicle. All this is cheap and easy, in contrast with EV where V2G (which would theoretically allow such usage) is a "capability".

(Here insert a joke about carrying Internet in buckets).

Re:All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035 by seydor on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:52AM (#33421989)
well..... without any ICE engines left the armies would have to wait until they are 80% charged before they invade ...