News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry. by CamperBob on Sunday December 11, 2011 @07:34PM (#3341652)
The distinction is very important: a customer is someone who pays you money.

To Google and Facebook, users are just parameters to be optimized.

Re:Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry. by nl on Sunday December 11, 2011 @11:43PM (#3342299)
"you're not the customer you're the product"

It's such an attractive meme, isn't it? Short, straight to the point, and it seems to make sense. What could possibly be wrong?

Like most things, the explanation why it is wrong is subtle, and much longer than the seven words it takes to express.

But think about this: credit card machines are usually provided free to merchants. Merchants aren't the product, and the credit card companies certainly regard them as a customer...

Multi-sided markets[1] are much more common in real life than you'd think, and the subject of significant study[2]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-sided_market

[2] http://scholar.google.com.au/scholar?q=multi+sided+market...

Re:Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry. by danssig on Monday December 12, 2011 @08:07AM (#3343409)
>Merchants aren't the product

Of course they are! Have you ever actually seen a credit card commercial? What do they talk about? The color of their cards? How people feel when using them? No, the focus on what companies will accept them (e.g. "it's everywhere you want to be!").

This little rant you bring up every time someone points out the nature of for-free services is as off base as ever.

Re:Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry. by nl on Monday December 12, 2011 @09:44AM (#3343639)
Of course they are! Have you ever actually seen a credit card commercial? What do they talk about? The color of their cards? How people feel when using them? No, the focus on what companies will accept them (e.g. "it's everywhere you want to be!").

Look again: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OolP9gNLP6c

Look how much business they are doing! How much quick to process it is compared to cash!

You are right of course - most mass market ads focus on the consumers, not the merchants. BUT the merchants are customers too, and it is the consumers that credit cards attractive to merchants. Classic multi-sided market.

This little rant you bring up every time someone points out the nature of for-free services is as off base as ever.

I'm glad it is being noticed.

Re:Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry. by okoni on Monday December 12, 2011 @05:03AM (#3343019)
"If you are not paying for it, you're not the customer; you're the product being sold." is the correct sentence [1], also you are welcome to explain why it's wrong according to you, but imho you are mistaken.

[1] http://www.metafilter.com/95152/Userdriven-discontent#325604...

Re:Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry. by nl on Monday December 12, 2011 @09:47AM (#3343646)
is the correct sentence

I got the quote from [1]. You may well be correct about the original version - I was trying to make it as short and clear as possible. I'm not sure it matters too much, though.

[1] http://techland.time.com/2010/10/15/facebook-youre-not-the-c...

Re:Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry. by danilocampos on Sunday December 11, 2011 @07:52PM (#3341706)
Concur: To lose a customer is to lose some chunk of revenue. To lose a user is to lose some chunk of page views to be sold. A very important distinction. You can offset shed users by adjusting the product to generate more page views, as publishers well know. Lose too many customers, though, and that's a lot of money that's simply not hitting your pocket anymore.

With that in mind, I'm pretty sure Netflix would not email me asking to know about the quality of a given streamed movie if I were merely a user.

And the way I know that is that YouTube has never once checked in on me to see how my streaming experience went.

Re:Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry. by nmridul on Sunday December 11, 2011 @09:36PM (#3341989)
I disagree with it. If I am conducting a free for all art exhibition (no selling of arts, just for people to see), then the visitors are not my customers. They are just viewers. I could have advertisers or sponsors for that program and someone could even be paying me based on the number of visitors. That does not make the visitors my customers.

On a side note- even if I lose my staff, I lose some chunk or revenue, that does not make my staff my customer.

Re:Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry. by magicalist on Sunday December 11, 2011 @08:44PM (#3341850)
if you wrote out your first paragraph in an actual formula, you would realize what you're missing here. You can't always generate more page views, so gaining or retaining users would then become what you want to maximize (as publishers wish they could). Lose advertisers, get more users or make the ads more effective and earn more. Make a product that users and advertisers like, and you maybe get more of both. Finding the sweet spot remains hard. Ignoring these dynamics is not helpful.

Your point about adwords customers getting someone on the phone is important, because not all adwords customers can. Preferential treatment for large customers is not at all unusual, and I don't think anyone would argue that it is bad. They just want a phone number they can call too.

Netflix and Youtube have completely different streaming models (namely youtube's is not adaptive), but I do see a "report a bug" link on there. But this ignores my point, which was not that google customer service is awesome, just that there definitely is a feedback loop ("there is zero incentive machinery"), and that "product not a customer" still misses the point as much as it ever has.

Re:Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry. by magicalist on Sunday December 11, 2011 @08:28PM (#3341808)
only at a completely shortsighted first approximation. Any policy they have regarding advertisers are parameters to optimize revenue as well.

However, you write "to be optimized", so clearly you agree with my original comment. Catchphrase away, then.