Re:Ousterhout: It's time to replace TCP in the Datacenter [pdf]
by patrec on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:45AM
(#33403345)
> De-facto standard discovery mechanism DNS does not work with ports
Yes, it does, see SRV records.
Re:Ousterhout: It's time to replace TCP in the Datacenter [pdf]
by friendzis on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:34AM
(#33403606)
I meant DNS A/AAAA queries with preconfigured/well-known ports being the default. While some applications/protocols/services do use some port discovery mechanism, I would argue it is nowhere close to being de-facto standard.
Re:Ousterhout: It's time to replace TCP in the Datacenter [pdf]
by bewo001 on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:12AM
(#33405938)
So true, but how many developers know about them? The API situation does not help either.
Re:Ousterhout: It's time to replace TCP in the Datacenter [pdf]
by AtNightWeCode on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:43PM
(#33408437)
I would say ports are mainly a problem on layers below transport even though some tech overuse ports.
I think this is more of an artefact of horizontal scaling and port-contention. De-facto standard discovery mechanism DNS does not work with ports, so "well-known port" abstraction kinda fails. Http as tunnel mostly avoids/sidesteps this problem.
> We should have a way to forward every single layer of the stack across each hop, and return back each layer of the stack, so that we can programmatically determine the exact causes of network issues, automatically diagnose them, and inform the user how to solve them.
This is weird take or I don't understand it. If you can communicate with an edge node in another network, but the edge node has issues communicating with some inner node (on your behalf), then, as a user, you have no hope of fixing that connectivity issue anyway, regardless of whether layered approach is used or not. This may be related to previous point about http as universal tunnel. Yes, this is a problem, but in a way that communications are effectively terminated at the edge node and monstrosity of stuff happens behind the scenes