Re:No Copyright Intended
by HotKFreshSwag on Sunday December 11, 2011 @12:03PM
(#3340396)
Or, these "kids" understands copyright and did some economical analysis and figured out that the increased spending power that comes from the money saved by copying content at zero cost was more beneficial to the economy than any benefits gained by having content protectionism.
Re:No Copyright Intended
by georgieporgie on Sunday December 11, 2011 @01:24PM
(#3340603)
As the creator of intellectual property, my first priority is putting food on the table. The macro-economic benefit of trading my intellectual property is irrelevant to me.
Or, these "kids" figured out the message is a lie.
> If you want to incentivize creators, you shouldn't copy their stuff.
They do not have the legal possibility to not want to incentivize creators. In practice, they also do not have a possibility to even vote on this, and they know that basically never anyone has voted on copyright but the companies profiting from copyright. It is like a purchased law totally shielded off from democracy.
Re:No Copyright Intended
by jessriedel on Sunday December 11, 2011 @12:21PM
(#3340437)
A lot of people disagree with you. When talking to folk in their 50's (I'm in my 20's) about this stuff, I often hear how intuitive it is that both copyright owners and patent owners should be paid for their work. Not just to create incentives, but because it's just in the absence of law.
Of course they should be paid for their work. But that doesn't mean that they should be able to restrict distribution. Thomas Jefferson argued that copyright protections are not natural, and in fact the US law specifically puts limits on which rights copyright holders can claim, and for how many years. http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/a1_8_8s12....
It may be true, but I'm inclined to think that they just got used to things being that way, so it feels normal to them.
Re:No Copyright Intended
by guard-of-terra on Sunday December 11, 2011 @12:15PM
(#3340424)
But why shouldn't you remix and derive their stuff?
Re:No Copyright Intended
by spacemanaki on Sunday December 11, 2011 @12:17PM
(#3340430)
Putting all of Pulp Fiction on YouTube hardly counts as a remix.
Re:No Copyright Intended
by guard-of-terra on Sunday December 11, 2011 @12:24PM
(#3340449)
Putting it in a different order does count. The problem there is that you can experience the remix instead of the original, essentially replacing it. So it's on the border.
But most of other cases are when derived product can't replace the original. In this case, we should adamantly demand that the creation of derived work is by default allowed, or else we lose all creative work that could be derived from original, which is a very bad thing in the same moral system where you operate.
Re:No Copyright Intended
by marcusramberg on Sunday December 11, 2011 @12:22PM
(#3340445)
It does if you reorder the scenes in chronological order.
Re:No Copyright Intended
by spacemanaki on Sunday December 11, 2011 @12:27PM
(#3340457)
Oops, you're right, I didn't read the OP carefully and forgot that Pulp Fiction isn't originally in chronological order.
If you want to incentivize creators, you shouldn't copy their stuff.
That's the message that never got communicated to these "kids".