News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by pessimizer on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:11PM (#33399385)
The weirdest part is that the Star Trek revival was shepherded by Rick Berman, who leaned very conservative, but the show stayed techno-utopian. Now that the show is explicitly woke (in the modern sense), it's become unbelievably authoritarian and militaristic.

I had to bail on Discovery when the Federation turned down an (gimmick-verified) honest offer of universal peace at the conclusion of a season because of their deep desire to punish and humiliate the enemy that was offering it to them. I hope the Federation was written as the evil empire from then on, but I'm not going to be there to see it. In the world of Discovery, the return of the Federation is obviously the biggest threat to the galaxy.

-----

edit: I have to admit that the Federation turning down the offer made me more angry than anything I had seen in fiction for years, so if it was a trick that they played with or overturned in the next season, they sure got me. I mean they lost me, because I bailed, but they got the emotion they were going for.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by shadowgovt on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:53PM (#33399858)
If you're referring to the Emerald Chain plot, I think you may have missed the point.

The party offering wasn't interested in rule of law. There was no long-term peace to be had with authoritarians who would only be content with peace as long as it was peace that put them above the law.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by pessimizer on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:02PM (#33399961)
That's exactly the point of view that I'm condemning, so it looks like I did understand it and they didn't reverse it. The "rule of law" (with scare quotes because there is no in-universe government of the galaxy to be violating the laws of) was the desire to punish the "authoritarian" who was making an honest offer of unconditional peace. Please save us from that rule-of-law, and deliver us to the authoritarians.
Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by shadowgovt on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:14PM (#33400051)
Yes. All of Earth would have had peace had they merely accepted the rule of Khan and his supermen.

... of all the deviations from Roddenberry's vision one could criticize Discovery for, I think this criticism fits least.

(They didn't "reverse" it so much as Osyraa died in the subsequent events that season and since the Chain was authoritarian, it collapsed without its mafia boss at the head. Dictatorships are such fragile things).

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by pessimizer on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:32PM (#33400177)
If Khan honestly (and verifiably) offers the Earth an unconditional end to a devastating war that they he and his forces were entirely equipped to continue indefinitely, anybody who turns him down (because they won't get to personally try and execute Khan) is a psychopath who thinks life is a game. If you think Roddenberry would think that was cool, I disagree, but I'd be happy to condemn Roddenberry, too. I'm not bothered by "deviations from Roddenberry's vision" as much as I'm bothered by a show that requires me to identify with objectively awful people to enjoy it.

---

edit:

> Dictatorships are such fragile things

You know that the writers choose how things turn out, right? It wasn't a real dictatorship, so you shouldn't take any life lessons from how it ended. There won't be any deus ex machina in real life to save elites from the consequences of similar decisions.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by shadowgovt on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:45PM (#33400279)
IIRC the plot correctly, the notion wasn't the admiral would "personally execute" Osyraa, it's that she would be tried for her crimes. I think even under Emerald Chain law, not Federation law (though I can't quite recall to that level of detail).

She refused, for obvious reasons.

It's a tad fraught to speculate what Roddenberry would have thought of the new Star Trek, but he fought in World War II so I'd imagine he'd understand the position that one does not accept the peace terms of, well, rulers who place themselves in a position where they are the only authority.

> you shouldn't take any life lessons from how it ended

Agreed. For example, I don't worry over-much about whether Admiral Vance's adherence to the principles of Starfleet over a tenuous peace that would last until the dictator across the table decided it had ended wouldn't make for good realpolitik. In reality, countries make strange bedfellows when dealing with powerful opponents all the time. Of course, history suggests those decisions have consequences, but c'est la réalité.

> There won't be any deus ex machina in real life to save elites from the consequences of similar decisions.

I sure hope not.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by pessimizer on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:52PM (#33400336)
> it's that she would be tried for her crimes.

It's that she was going to be given a show trial for crimes she was obviously guilty of and that would obviously deserve the worst penalty that the system could deliver. So it was to be pointless humiliation before pointless execution.

> he fought in World War II so I'd imagine he'd understand the position that one does not accept the peace terms of, well, rulers who place themselves in a position where they are the only authority.

Is this about that one time when Hitler offered the world unconditional peace and the world turned it down in exchange for the hope of maybe one day bringing him to trial?

> a tenuous peace that would last until the dictator across the table decided it had ended

I was hoping this is what the story was about, but the mechanical lie detector machine gimmick that couldn't be fooled said that this was not the case. Any secret treachery is something that you're adding that the writers made explicitly impossible to add.

> history suggests those decisions have consequences

Exactly what historical parallel are you pointing to that involved a magic truth machine?

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by shadowgovt on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:55PM (#33400354)
> for crimes she was obviously guilty of

If she was obviously guilty, then wouldn't rule of law indicate she should be held accountable?

If she isn't held accountable, what is the nature of the government formed by the Emerald Chain / Federation alliance?

ETA: lies aren't necessary. Osyraa could 100% believe what she was saying in the moment. But that's the thing about those who are above the law... The next day, she could decide something else was more expedient, change her mind, and break the peace. There would be nothing to hold her to account if she did, and she had clearly been indicated to be an opportunist and a power-broker.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by pessimizer on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:59PM (#33400389)
When there is no such thing as a galactic government, there's no such thing as galactic law.

> If she isn't held accountable, what is the nature of the government formed by the Emerald Chain / Federation alliance?

They literally had a truth machine. If they cared, they could just ask.

> The next day, she could decide something else was more expedient, change her mind, and break the peace.

So could the Federation. So could anyone, so that really precludes anyone dealing with anyone else because even though they could be honestly dealing today, maybe at some later date everything could change.

All of these excuses require facts that are not in evidence, or that were explicitly contradicted by the plot. I wouldn't trade one innocent life for the chance to execute a dictator who has completely stood down. The Federation was willing to exchange uncountable ones.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by shadowgovt on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:06PM (#33400439)
> So could the Federation

That would be counter to the Federation's principles. And that's the point. The ways-of-life on the table in the negotiation are "You do what you have to do" vs. "You do what you should."

Taking a step back from the immediate conversation: We've gone several posts deep in point-counterpoint on the decision made in this episode, and I think you are making excellent points. I'm pleased this decision can be looked at from multiple valid points-of-view supported with conviction. That's what the best Star Trek writing is made of.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by pessimizer on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:10PM (#33400468)
If the point is that the Federation gradually degenerated into a militaristic death cult. They neither did what they had to do, or what they should have done. They chose the pleasure of her submission to their authority over an honest peace.

edit: this sort of thinking really gets on my nerves because it happens in the real world. Any number of innocent corpses are justified if some particular enemy individual can be punished. It really makes it clear that for some people life is a game between elites to dominate each other, and most people aren't players, they're the board.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by shadowgovt on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:14PM (#33400485)
Sorry; I still can't see it that way. I'm seeing the Federation adhering to their principles and being unwilling to compromise with a pirate queen because there's no lasting peace to be built on that foundation. Osyraa can believe there is enough to pass the magic-lie-bot test and still just be wrong because she doesn't understand that peace through dictatorial strength will not hold.

It's not about her submission; it's about justice. If she's not accountable, then why would her lieutenants be? Or their lieutenants? Or anyone, for the openly-practiced slavery and exploitation in the Chain? There's no peace without justice to be had, not really.

Vance was being asked to declare "In the interest of peace, all this slavery was nobody's fault," and that's a non-starter.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by pessimizer on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:17PM (#33400512)
Gandhi reminded us that's a recipe for apocalypse.

> Vance was being asked to declare "In the interest of peace, all this slavery was nobody's fault," and that's a non-starter.

If your choice is to free the slaves, or punish the slaver, which do you pick? If you choose to punish the slaver over freeing the slaves, are you putting your own ego above the suffering of people who you clearly don't particularly value?

edit: did anyone at the Federation know any slaves? Did they ask them if they would rather be free than hold out as slaves for a trial in an indeterminate future? If the Federation managed to capture her and free the slaves, would the trial be nutritious for the slaves? Would it clothe or house them? Would it deter anyone else from becoming a warlord?

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by shadowgovt on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:23PM (#33400550)
> If your choice is to free the slaves, or punish the slaver, which do you pick?

False dichotomy. As an American, it sometimes rubs the wrong way when that's presented as either-or because the US chose not to punish many of the slavers and we continue to live with the consequences of that decision: they regained power and built the Jim Crow South.

Justice is required for lasting peace. It perhaps need not be fatal, but it must be real.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by samus on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:53PM (#33399859)
It was a controversial decision also in-universe. The Admiral had to make it because otherwise he would have had to throw out of the window any pretense of clinging to the old ideals and to the rule of law. That would have destroyed everything that distinguished the Federation from an aging space empird that tries to keep itself together at all costs.

Spoiler: Conveniently, the unfolding events saved the Federation from the consequences that this decision would have otherwise had. And in the end, they ascended again, even though Vulcan^H^H^H^H^H^H Ni'var made it very clear that their rejoining was very much conditional.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by pessimizer on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:08PM (#33400015)
> he would have had to throw out of the window any pretense of clinging to the old ideals and to the rule of law. That would have destroyed everything that distinguished the Federation from an aging space empire that tries to keep itself together at all costs.

That sounds to me like an aging space empire who wouldn't exchange its pompous unearned claims of moral superiority for what could have been untold billions of lives. And apparently, in the end they were saved by the writers from the consequences of that action.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by shadowgovt on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:52PM (#33400331)
> saved by the writers

Not really. Plot of the next season has as background action the hard work of rebuilding, planet-by-planet, the old alliances that had fallen apart when the Federation collapsed.

(But then a galaxy-wide threat shows up so there's something else to worry about)

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by pessimizer on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:06PM (#33400445)
Saved by the writers in that they kill her, rather than her leaving and killing billions more that would have lived if the Federation had been concerned with human life over vengeance.
Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by samus on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:40AM (#33421078)
The Federation had moral superiority already by the basic fact that its members joined voluntarily, and that they let them leave in peace.