News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by PhasmaFelis on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:51PM (#33399164)
> It’s not realistic because it’s fundamentally either autistic

Say what, now?

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by Supermancho on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:06PM (#33399332)
> either autistic or straight up dehumanizing and authoritarian

It's important to note that in STTNG, Star Fleet is not the entirety of the human population in the show. This concept is often overlooked. The idea that human interpersonal dysfunction is a psychological and maslow-dependent side-effect is abhorrent to some people. It's seen as dehumanizing because such an observer is not able to connect with any of the characters. The assumption is that the writers have somehow taken away their humanity for them to be psychologically stable, mature, and well-adapted individuals. Read into that what you will. This is supposed to be "utopian" despite the obvious conflicts that arise, nonetheless.

Orville does something similar, but magnifies the differences and interpersonal conflicts in a fun way.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by fuckstick on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:04PM (#33399975)
> It's important to note that in STTNG, Star Fleet is not the entirety of the human population in the show.

Oh that’s right, they’re often comically overtly racist caricatures.

In any event Star Fleet specifically is a dystopian hell has been analyzed to death. And the genesis of DS9 is completely straightforward. You can use the idealized yet completely ridiculous portrayal of Star Fleet for a movie or two, some short stories. Stretching it out to 7 seasons was admirable (but even they had to make some concessions with story arcs post Roddenberry). Let’s not forget TOS only needed to last 3 seasons and the Roddenberry era TNG is pretty crappy overall at least outside the diehard fandom.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by uxcolumbo on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:03PM (#33400424)
Can you provide more details about how DS9 or Star Fleet is dystopian. Or links to those articles?

I didn't get the dystopian vibe at all when watching TNG, DS9, Voyager or Enterprise.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by fuckstick on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:34PM (#33400638)
Seriously you can Google it. This is well trodden ground.
Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by PhasmaFelis on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:15PM (#33415261)
If you're going to make extraordinary claims, you need to provide evidence, not just say "Google it."

I did Google it, though, and found the expected handful of thinkpieces and Reddit posts. Obviously the shows have fallen short or aged poorly at times, and people have discussed that the same way they've discussed everything else about Star Trek. I'm not seeing evidence for your claim that "Star Trek is dystopian" is a settled conclusion.

Also, I'm still waiting to hear what "fundamentally autistic" means.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by Supermancho on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:52PM (#33400762)
> In any event Star Fleet specifically is a dystopian hell has been analyzed to death.

Analysis about the dystopian back-workings is fan fiction. It's all fiction, to be sure, but the topic is constrained. STTNG portrays a society, in good faith that it's harmonious. This article is about STTNG, not DS9.

Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by fuckstick on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:01PM (#33399278)
The themes are hyperfixated on a few aspects of a utopia and human behavior with complete deafness to everything else. That’s the charitable take. The less charitable one is it is a type of willful indoctrination.
Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by manmal on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:58PM (#33399908)
I fail to see how you’d make a scifi TV series that isn’t what you just described. What do you mean by “everything else”?
Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by fuckstick on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:26PM (#33400137)
Yeah, no, not going down this rabbithole. If you’re already convinced STTOS and TNG were the pinnacle achievements of SciFi TV entertainment then we just have to agree to disagree.
Re:Ursula Le Guin on Star Trek: TNG (1994) by manmal on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:03PM (#33400420)
I never wrote that? Sheesh, why are you commenting at all if you don’t even want to clarify what you commented in the first place.