Planning on this great new "hydrogen economy" thing when even the best-case theoretical technologies represent only a mild improvement over what we have isn't responsible punditry, it's just playing "What if George Jetson had a Jetpack?" games.
Burning remainders of dinosaurs is on the decline. It is frowned upon by many due to CO2, it is not always readily available (see current war), and finally supply is limited. This leads to a decrease of availability, and at continuing demand an increase in price. Unavoidable.
Prduction of electrical power from renewables is the cheapest form available already today. Also, it can scale without any practical limit. Power just isn't always available when needed, with surplus production at other times. Any improvement in storage cost (mainly device cost, much less efficiency) decreases the price of power from storage.
At some point, the price of power from storage will drop below the price of power from fossil fuels. No magic step will be needed, simply increasing/decreasing prices will meet at some point.
These kind of breakthroughs change the economics and composition of the new energy economy. They are not a challenge to the fact that harmful, limited, fossil energy is a very cheap and simple way to run an economy for a century or so.
Of course, improvement at storage will always be good. It's just not the bottleneck right now.
So, yeah, the article is great news. And it won't change the electricity paradigm at all. Both at the same time.
That's already the case in the northern parts of Germany. On windy days feeding excessive electricity to all neighbors, and still shutting down some wind turbines. The local energy company is planning 320 MW hydrogen production [0].
[0] https://www.ewe.com/de/media-center/pressemitteilungen/2022/...
In regards to the efficiency argument against hydrogen: Sometimes that is an issue but sometimes it’s just not an issue at all. Fossil fuel efficiency is abominable but they’re still used.
I know hydrogen is hard to store, so I think it would be best if we could somehow use electricity to produce ethanol directly from CO2 and water (is that feasible with reasonable efficiency?). But just imagine if we could, in the summer, we could turn excess solar power into ethanol and stockpile it for the winter. We could also use that fuel to power jet airplanes and cargo ships without using any fossil fuels.
I wonder if a truly 100% discharged battery (down to zero volts) would actually be basically inert, and not even smolder if you poked it.
I think the real value of water-sourced hydrogen is going to be in three fields: synthesis of ammonia (atmospheric N2 + H2 -> NH3), direct reduction of iron ore to sponge iron (FeO + H2 -> Fe), and synthesis of methane and jet fuel (Sabatier and Fischer-Tropsch processes, respectively).
In Germany there's also plans to repurpose gas plants to burn H2 during Dunkelflaute. I'm curious if that will pan out.
But here's the thing: PEM electrolysis promises to reach hydrogen production efficiencies of... 80% or so, using exotic materials and entirely new chemistries. Regular DC electrical electrolysis (literally the "stick a wire in water to make bubbles" experiment we all did as kids) is starting out around the 65-70% mark. This just isn't that much better.
And doubly so when you realize that the most efficient reconversion of that hydrogen to electricity is going to lose another 20%.
This is better, but it's only incrementally better. 30% cheaper hydrogen would be nice, I guess, but it's not going to change any fundamentals of the energy economy.