News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by jpxxx on Friday December 09, 2011 @01:58PM (#3335020)
Honest question: to what end is this happening? They receive no money from a sale of the project, they still have to commit engineering resources, they lose some level of control over its development and its future,and how is it going to be placed into someone else's aboveboard commercial mobile product if there aren't any guarantees against patent attacks?

What is the upside?

Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by tewolde on Friday December 09, 2011 @02:25PM (#3335155)
This is a platform play. Think of it like a casino, HP is the house. It sits in the middle, makes the rules and pockets the mindshare, influence...and maybe some money.

Samsung, HTC have been desperate for an alternative to android since the Motorola purchase by Google. If HP does this right, I have little doubt we will see future webOS devices.

Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by TomOfTTB on Friday December 09, 2011 @02:59PM (#3335307)
If these companies are "desperate for an alternative" why didn't they embrace webOS before? Or why aren't they pushing Windows Mobile?

Or, if they want open, why not just fork Android like Amazon and Barnes and Noble? Are you seriously suggesting Barnes and Noble has more technical resources than HTC and Samsung?

Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by masklinn on Friday December 09, 2011 @03:02PM (#3335318)
> why didn't they embrace webOS before?

Because they could not? The only way they could was to buy it from HP, and that costs money.

> Or why aren't they pushing Windows Mobile?

HTC has WP handsets out.

> Or, if they want open, why not just fork Android like Amazon and Barnes and Noble? Are you seriously suggesting Barnes and Noble has more technical resources than HTC and Samsung?

B&N customizes Android by cutting down on features to pare it down to a tablet, the requirements are... lower.

Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by TomOfTTB on Friday December 09, 2011 @03:56PM (#3335570)
> Because they could not? The only way they could was to buy it from HP, and that costs money.

The money saved on software licensing isn't enough to make the difference if these companies were "desperate" for an alternative. As you pointed out HTC is making Windows Mobile handsets right now and it costs money.

(Though again my point on HTC was they'd be pushing WP if they were desperate to get away from Android and they aren't)

> B&N customizes Android by cutting down on features to pare it down to a tablet, the requirements are... lower.

What features has B&N paired down in the Nook? They've restricted the use of some features but they haven't removed anything that I know of. Meaning what they have done is add a shell on top of Android just as any other manufacturer could do.

Even if you buy the argument that it would be harder for Samsung and HTC to adopt webOS feature into a shell you can't argue that it would be harder than switching to an entirely new OS and putting the marketing budget into it to attract development.

If that were easy HP would have done it.

Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by tewolde on Friday December 09, 2011 @05:27PM (#3335927)
It's all about hedging your bets. Until today, android was the only open source platform these companies could use. This gave Google an advantage to define the rules. For example, they could actually start closing parts of the source or giving Motorola preferential treatment.

Google had the sole power to define what an "open" platform was and the rules in using it. Developers, telcos and HW companies now have a second option.

HP may not make a dime from this move, but if the move is cheap and it can cost the competition more to respond, then it is a move is well played.

Lastly, HP is a hardware/software/services company so this move will give it some leverage when dealing with large players in those areas.

Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by masklinn on Friday December 09, 2011 @03:04PM (#3335330)
Samsung has bada already, I don't think they've been desperate for much. HTC, yes. I can see Acer, LG and Sony in that latter category as well.
Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by robbrown451 on Friday December 09, 2011 @02:25PM (#3335156)
I think HP would benefit if the mobile/tablet landscape was not so dominated and controlled by two of their competitors
Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by steele on Friday December 09, 2011 @02:38PM (#3335224)
The fire sale puts them in a decent position against Android.
Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by jnbiche on Friday December 09, 2011 @02:25PM (#3335161)
And the upside of Google doing the same to Android was?
Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by mikecane on Friday December 09, 2011 @02:41PM (#3335238)
Google gets Google Search on devices. And HP will get ... oops. A piece is missing here.
Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by mikecane on Friday December 09, 2011 @03:13PM (#3335376)
I figured out the piece: the webOS App Catalog. Keep it going. Future profit justifies webOS continued development.
Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by jpxxx on Friday December 09, 2011 @03:34PM (#3335491)
I don't think there's remotely enough money in apps to justify future development. This OS will need hundreds of millions of dollars in development to stay competitive and it's not starting with a userbase of any real size.
Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by bmajz on Saturday December 10, 2011 @12:29AM (#3337023)
It could be a good way for them to claim "units" of sale vs. Apple since iOS+Mac already has Apple in a strong second in PC sales. There's some face to be saved in being the top PC seller. Oh wait, Apothekar already tried to jettison that.
Re:HP to Contribute webOS to Open Source by jdthomas on Friday December 09, 2011 @02:15PM (#3335100)
Upside: They look slightly less foolish?