Re:Brave New Trusted Boot World
by TeMPOraL on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @09:05AM
(#33343043)
> Your device your rules seems to cover this, too: they’re saying they don’t want to do business under other rules – the app is just showing the UI for that policy client side.
I guess I see two problems here:
1) They shouldn't be allowed to make that policy in the first place. Their policy is effectively dictating what devices I can own and what can I do with them, which is unreasonable when the devices in question are general-purpose computers.
2) My device is being used against me and against my wishes here; I'm not sure who's more to blame here - the bank for taking advantage of the API, Google for providing it, or the phone vendor for implementing it and locking me out of it, or Google again for effectively forcing the phone vendor to lock me out of it.
> I miss the free-for-all of the 90s in some ways but statistically zero of the non-IT people I know wouldn’t hand root on their phone over to some guy in another country based on a prompt on a webpage.
There must be some other way of handling it. We wouldn't have the Fisher-Price tech of 2020s without the free-for-all 90s! The ability for technically proficient users to do whatever the hell they want with their own general-purpose computers is fundamental to developing new technologies, products and services, and better alternatives to existing ones. Between Fisher-Price consumer tech and locked down corporate tech (because security!), it looks like we're heading for an era where a general-purpose computer will be something available only to few certified employees in corporate-sponsored labs.
I guess I see two problems here:
1) They shouldn't be allowed to make that policy in the first place. Their policy is effectively dictating what devices I can own and what can I do with them, which is unreasonable when the devices in question are general-purpose computers.
2) My device is being used against me and against my wishes here; I'm not sure who's more to blame here - the bank for taking advantage of the API, Google for providing it, or the phone vendor for implementing it and locking me out of it, or Google again for effectively forcing the phone vendor to lock me out of it.
> I miss the free-for-all of the 90s in some ways but statistically zero of the non-IT people I know wouldn’t hand root on their phone over to some guy in another country based on a prompt on a webpage.
There must be some other way of handling it. We wouldn't have the Fisher-Price tech of 2020s without the free-for-all 90s! The ability for technically proficient users to do whatever the hell they want with their own general-purpose computers is fundamental to developing new technologies, products and services, and better alternatives to existing ones. Between Fisher-Price consumer tech and locked down corporate tech (because security!), it looks like we're heading for an era where a general-purpose computer will be something available only to few certified employees in corporate-sponsored labs.