Yes, I accounted for that by mentioning the alternate possibility of extremely heavy users. A typical user (a few nights a week) shouldn't pay much mind to this study, and likely neither should someone who primarily vapes or consumes edibles.
> The definition of marijuana (Cannabis) dependence (addiction) contains three critical elements. These are (a) preoccupation with the acquisition of marijuana, (b) compulsive use of marijuana, (c) relapse to or recurrent use of the marijuana.
It reminds me of the best description of alcoholism I read, via a charity, that pointed out it was a mistake to think of it in terms of heavy drinking but whether someone was able to control their drinking (or more accurately, themselves when drink is around). If you can't turn down a drink, or you find there are environments where you can't turn down a drink, you're not in control. That's what leads to heavy drinking but they're not the same thing.
Control is part of it, but there are other aspects as well. Many of them deal with control, but not all. Meaning you could ostensibly be “in control” and still be diagnosed with a substance abuse disorder.
- Taking the substance in larger amounts or for longer than you're meant to
- Wanting to cut down or stop using the substance but not managing to
- Spending a lot of time getting, using, or recovering from use of the substance
- Cravings and urges to use the substance
- Not managing to do what you should at work, home, or school because of substance use
- Continuing to use, even when it causes problems in relationships
- Giving up important social, occupational, or recreational activities because of substance use
- Using substances again and again, even when it puts you in danger
- Continuing to use, even when you know you have a physical or psychological problem that could have been caused or made worse by the substance
- Needing more of the substance to get the effect you want (tolerance)
- Development of withdrawal symptoms, which can be relieved by taking more of the substance
[1] https://www.verywellmind.com/dsm-5-criteria-for-substance-us...
The argument you’re making is flawed because it’s based on the users perception of a problem and not the standardized clinical definition. People (especially addicts) are not wholly rational. People will rationalize away a problem to suit their irrational biases. If a substance is detrimental to my health and I say “well, I don’t care. I could quit if I wanted to” it doesn’t negate the fact that it’s still detrimental to one’s health. It’s still a substance abuse problem by the clinical definition even if I’m claiming to be “in control”. If your doctor diagnoses you with obesity and you claim you can diet if you wanted to, it doesn’t make your obesity diagnosis moot. Your perception of self control doesn’t impact the objective diagnosis.
Your take is a bit like the way people say the best way to solve the problems with illegal drugs is to make drug use legal. (And FWIW I’m pretty libertarian on this issue) Sure, by definition it’s no longer a legal problem but it’s a bit of a hand wavy effort that leaves most of the residual problems intact. It just reframes it in a way that ignores them.
It’s also one of the problems with modern debate in that anyone can “do their own research” (which often means just reading an abstract that suits their confirmation bias without a grounded understanding of the full context). It devolves into rules-lawyering where people argue about what the definition of “is” is. We have standardized definitions for a reason.
It's a very strange assumption to make given we're discussing clinical diagnosis. Surely the most usual set of circumstances is that a user seeks help because they have (or perceive) a problem and a clinician diagnoses them. There certainly can be others that include self-diagnosis but you should really start from the usual, especially if you're going to avoid unintentionally building straw men.
It doesn't matter who's making the decision about control. Even if a doctor thinks you're capable of controlling your diet, it doesn't make their clinical diagnosis of obesity go away. Either you meet the clinical definition or not. If you have the utmost ability to control your diet but still have a BMI of 60, guess what, you've still got an obesity problem.
> A definitive diagnosis entails confirming the presence of addictive behavior by identifying a preoccupation, compulsivity and relapse relative to the drug
Preoccupation is a lack of control.
Compulsivity(sic) is a lack of control.
Relapse is a lack of control.
In fact, the authors of that paper wrote a book about alcohol abuse[1] that is littered with quotes about control, like “These criteria reflect the loss of control over alcohol that is central to the diagnosis of alcoholism” or “The loss of control over the self and the alcoholic is present in the enabler as it is present in the alcoholic”, or my favourite:
> The behavioral criteria describe the loss of control over alcohol that leads to the adverse consequences
As to this claim by you:
> Even if a doctor thinks you're capable of controlling your diet, it doesn't make their clinical diagnosis of obesity go away"
They're not (or haven't been) capable of controlling their diet, that's why they're obese, and that's why they're getting help from a professional, but regardless, you've chosen a poor analogy. Someone with an addiction to eating or sugar would be much better, as obesity is a consequence of their actions, just as "Not managing to do what you should at work, home, or school because of substance use" would be an possible consequence of marijuana dependency.
[1] https://books.google.com.au/books?id=NrHzBwAAQBAJ&q=control#...
>I provided the definition, and I also provided a paper
Yes, but did you notice that the paper you cited is from 1989? And that I cited the more modern DSM V, which did not exist when that paper was published? Also note that you keep using the term "dependence" and I'm using "substance use". This is because the terminology was deliberately changed in the DSM V. In 2007, they updated the terms to combine both "use" and "dependence" and merged them into a the category of "substance use". This includes the criteria that are not specifically related to the locus of control. This is what I mean about drawing strong conclusions from a paper when you don't know the fuller context.
I don't think you're understanding my point about control so I'll try one last time. I've already agreed that control is part of the definition; so I don't think we disagree there. But I am saying the definition goes beyond just the idea of control. It's possible to have the capability of control, but not exercise that control. That doesn't make the clinical diagnosis go away. Keeping with the obesity analogy, consider a sumo wrestler who is, by clinical definition, morbidly obese. They could very well have phenomenal willpower to control their diet, but choose not to because their chosen profession gets a benefit from being larger than their opponent. In some sense, they choose to be obese. Yet a clinician will still say they have an obesity problem. (It seems like you're assuming that, by the nature of their diagnosis, they are trying to fix it. i.e. 'trying to get help from a doctor'. That's assumption is not included in the distinction I'm making.)
Now transfer that to an addict. Many choose to chase a high at the cost of their family, career, and/or health. To them, it's a worthy tradeoff. And the way substances affect/change the manner that we decide those tradeoffs is very real. Even if they could stop cold-turkey, they still have a clinical substance abuse problem. Your assumption is that they want to stop because of those ramifications and can't. I'm saying that they may not want to stop. They're still addicts. That's the pernicious part of your definition; just because they're doing it willfully doesn't make the problem go away any more than legalizing drugs makes society's drug problems magically go away.
That would be very convenient for you so I'm glad I could help, I'd hate for you to challenge your preconceptions. I certainly wouldn't be able to think the same in return. How could it be so!
As to your next paragraph about the DSM where you've criticised the cited paper yet ignored the provision of the actual DSM-5 criteria in the following comment. The updates you point to were made to improve the capture of abuse in the diagnostic criteria, and that does not downplay the control aspect or go beyond it (or whatever strange angle you wish to provide). The idea that dependence does factor in control but abuse doesn't is absurd.
> This includes the criteria that are not specifically related to the locus of control
There are no criteria that do not relate to control.
> I don't think you're understanding my point about control so I'll try one last time.
Again, so convenient, but I'm very happy to see the words one last time, we'll see if your self control reaches that far.
> I get the impression you also agree here because you’re couching your statements to now include the “critical” (I.e., non-exhaustive) elements
Is that your impression? I'm amazed at how all of these insights into my intentions always align with your convenience. Funny that! What a run you're on.
Regardless, I started with the critical elements, you brought up the other elements, it makes no difference to my point either way.
> It's possible to have the capability of control,
Everyone without a pre-existing disorder has the capability of control.
> …but not exercise that control
So they're not in control then.
> That doesn't make the clinical diagnosis go away.
It wouldn't, because they're not in control. If they were, they wouldn't have a problem and wouldn't be able to meet any but one - if that - of the criteria on the list. Lack of control is a pre-condition.
> Keeping with the obesity analogy, consider a sumo wrestler
Here you repeat the faults of the previous attempt at this analogy, it's a restatement that does nothing to fundamentally improve it.
> A clinician will still say they have an obesity problem
Because obesity is a problem because of its negative health consequences despite any self control. A sumo's job is not affected, it is their job. It doesn't concern legal problems or wanting to stop etc, it concerns known health risks that they are (hopefully) aware of and decide to take on in full control. There's no compulsion from inside or out.
An addict is *not in control*. They don't make a trade off as they unable to choose another path, there's no trade going on, hence why the criteria are what they are, and hence your analogy being incredibly poor.
Your analogy would hold where someone with a known predisposition to some illness (mental or physical) or who has or had a illness decided to imbibe marijuana and this affect their health, like someone with COPD lighting up. But they wouldn't fulfil the marijuana dependence nor substance abuse criteria, they're in control. They'd still get a clinical diagnosis like that of the sumo but for their COPD, not substance abuse.
> Your assumption is that they want to stop because of those ramifications and can't. I'm saying that they may not want to stop.
How did you read my mind yet again? You didn't. Their desire to stop or continue are irrelevant, they can't stop.
> Even if they could stop cold-turkey, they still have a clinical substance abuse problem
They would possibly only fulfil one criteria (cravings and urges to use the substance), so no, they wouldn't. Objectively and according to the DSM, IV or 5.
I believe my wish to convenience your faultless mental processes has reached its limit.
Edit: I realized I said nothing about amount. I go through approximately 1/2 to 1 gram daily.
I wouldn’t dismiss it as bias. Marijuana dependence is a very real phenomenon, despite the pop culture “it’s not physically addictive” trope that tries to downplay drug dependence.
They’re looking at 22,000 out of 1.85 million patients, or around 1% of patients. They weren’t trying to look for casual or intermittent users.
Focusing on those diagnosed according to the criteria of marijuana dependence is the clearest way to remain objective and get a clear signal out of the study. Those with marijuana dependence are the people consuming frequently, and therefore likely to consume during the recovery period.