Re:IEEE Hosted Gitlab Instance
by defnotdallas on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:42AM
(#33331100)
Is it _really_ open source if even just viewing anything requires an account?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:IEEE Hosted Gitlab Instance
by boleary-gl on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:46AM
(#33331165)
You can explore the public projects here: https://opensource.ieee.org/explore
I wish there was a less email-centric workflow to contact the HN mods, because I think your link is much better than a sign in page for showing off the intended content
Re:IEEE Hosted Gitlab Instance
by TAForObvReasons on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:40AM
(#33332081)
The key phrase for licenses like MIT is "free of charge". It's fair game for IEEE to require registering for a free account to download from the source, but it's also fair game for one brave user to download and host elsewhere without the registration.
It's a discoverability problem of that particular page; as a sibling comment mentioned, it's possible to view the public project, it's just that this site has no link to /explore - just /search from what I could see.
Is it really open source if there's no repo at all? Absolutely
It’s perfectly valid for someone to just release tarballs of their source code releases. You don’t need a bunch of infrastructure to share software.
Re:IEEE Hosted Gitlab Instance
by scrollaway on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:50AM
(#33332230)
The GPL allows you to not publish the source, as long as you provide it on request. Several older “open source” projects were distributed exclusively by CD-ROM.
Re:IEEE Hosted Gitlab Instance
by dec0dedab0de on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:53PM
(#33335336)
Yes. Open source is about being able to modify and redistribute code for the products you already have access to. It's not about just giving everything to everyone.