Why do you think that?
There is a common article that gets passed around where a person tried to get copyright assigned to a machine and that keeps getting denied. That is very different from "AI generated images cannot be copyrighted".
If I write a program to randomly generate an image of squares of different colors:
- I, a human, can have copyright over the program text itself as a literary work
- I, a human, can have copyright over the image output of the program
I can't claim copyright on a work by an AI, because I'm not the author.
AI created works, like animal-created works [2], lack authorship, and are thus not eligible for copyright at all.
It's being litigated, and might change, but this is the current position of the US Copyright Office [1].
The only AI generated copyrighted work at the moment is a graphic novel, Zarya of the Dawn, and was granted a copyright as 'visual material', not 'visual arts work'. The most likely legal interpretation of which is that the author has added copyrightable material to non-copyrightable material, and obtained a copyright on the addition [3].
[1] https://www.techdirt.com/2022/08/15/dude-who-keeps-suing-to-...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_selfie_copyright_disput...
Is there any source for this? The only things I can find are people trying to assert non humans as copyright holders and being told no.
So, at least in this instance, the AI created the work with insufficient creative input from a person, and thus has no human author, and is not eligible for copyright.
https://www.copyright.gov/rulings-filings/review-board/docs/...
"Thaler does not assert that the Work was created with contribution from a human author"
All it takes is for the copyright submission for this Artist to say "I used a computer to generate this image through x y z steps selecting for q r s features until I was satisfied." I'm confident they would accept it.
This case is an attempt to set new precedent for copyright by granting it to a computer. And rightfully so, the Copyright office refuses to do so.
You can lie about authorship, and it will (probably) be undetectable/irrefutable.
Also, currently AI's are not given personhood under law, hence they are not the author of the work they create. Given that, it isn't much of a stretch to say that if you wrote the software that runs the AI, you are the author. Which is a problem for users of tools like DALL-E.
Are you claiming that whoever wrote Photoshop automatically owns digital art created in Photoshop if the artist of the digital art doesn't claim copyright?
https://www.copyright.gov/rulings-filings/review-board/docs/...
https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/which-ai-components-are-co...
Current AI is "really fancy automatic photoshop collage".
But no worries, an unknown part is shared with creators.
Two revenue streams without consent but they still present themselves as the ethical AI company.
And it's not even clear what a customer is buying. As far as I know, AI art can't be copyrighted.